Popular in Arts and Humanities

Arts and Humanities

Titus Quinctius Flamininus’ “Italian triumph”

McGill University Michael Fronda

Arts and Humanities

Lincoln and the Jews

Brandeis University Jonathan Sarna

Arts and Humanities

Amputations and Convalescence

University of Western Australia Emily Brink

Art

Drawing on the past: Palladio, his precursors and knowledge of ancient architecture

University of Birmingham David Hemsoll

Art

Language, Sound, and Image in Wallace Berman’s Aleph, 1956–1966

University of San Diego Chelsea Behle Fralick

Arts and Humanities

Early Modern Natural Law Theories

University of Copenhagen Knud Haakonssen

Holy Humanitarians

View more insights in Arts and Humanities - Books - History - Intellectual and Religious History

View more figures from Tufts University

View the page of Heather Curtis

Read the Study

In Holy Humanitarians, Heather D. Curtis argues that evangelical media campaigns transformed how Americans responded to domestic crises and foreign disasters during a pivotal period for the nation.

Image courtesy of interviewee. May 7, 2024

Generating Workspace

Export as PDF

This video video is a detailed discussion by a scholar who has researched the historical response of American Christians to suffering, particularly focusing on the late 19th century. The scholar's interest began with their first book, "Faith in the Great Physicians," which examined how Christians coped with physical suffering during a time of theological change and medical advancement. Subsequently, they explored how Christians responded to the suffering of others globally, including humanitarian disasters, war, and economic hardship, leading to their current work titled "Holy Humanitarians."

The Christian Herald Association, which published a major Christian newspaper from 1890 to 1910, played a significant role in these efforts by publicizing various forms of suffering and organizing charitable responses. The newspaper combined religious teachings on charity with modern journalism techniques to raise awareness and solicit funds for humanitarian efforts. Its leadership, including Louis Klos and Thomas DeWitt Talmage, emphasized that aiding the suffering was an obligation for all American Christians, transcending denominational boundaries.

The scholar highlights various initiatives supported by the Christian Herald, like orphanages and relief campaigns during famines, and the unique position of the Christian Herald as a faith-based alternative to more secular organizations like the American Red Cross. They also discuss how the Christian Herald drew connections between religious duty and national identity, promoting the idea of America as a morally responsible global force.

The narrative covers the challenges faced by the Christian Herald, particularly as new social movements emerged, and shifts occurred in both American humanitarianism and the landscape of charitable organizations. This video video concludes with reflections on the legacy of the Christian Herald, suggesting its influence persists in contemporary discussions about humanitarianism, social justice, and the responsibility of charitable organizations today. This video video encourages modern readers to recognize and learn from the historical dynamics of humanitarian aid as they continue to address current issues of poverty and suffering.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.145 --> 00:03.125
As a scholar, I've been interested in exploring

00:03.185 --> 00:04.925
how Christians define

00:04.945 --> 00:06.845
and deal with various kinds of suffering.

00:07.305 --> 00:09.845
So my first book was called Faith in the Great Physicians,

00:09.875 --> 00:13.565
suffering in Divine Healing in American Protestantism from

00:13.805 --> 00:15.005
1816 to 1900.

00:15.745 --> 00:18.085
And in that I explored how a group

00:18.085 --> 00:21.445
of Christians in the late 19th century US coped

00:21.445 --> 00:23.965
with physical illness, during a time

00:23.965 --> 00:25.845
of really great theological change

00:25.945 --> 00:28.445
and also innovation in the medical sciences.

00:29.345 --> 00:31.365
So when I got done with that book

00:31.385 --> 00:33.525
and I thought, okay, I've, I've thought about how it is

00:33.525 --> 00:36.645
that Christians deal with physical suffering within

00:36.645 --> 00:38.805
themselves, but what about suffering out in the world?

00:38.955 --> 00:41.445
What about when they encountered the suffering of others?

00:42.145 --> 00:44.885
How did they respond to various forms of suffering,

00:44.885 --> 00:49.125
like humanitarian disasters, famines, floods, earthquakes,

00:49.345 --> 00:52.965
suffering caused by war or imperialism

00:53.025 --> 00:54.565
or economic downturns?

00:55.225 --> 00:59.205
Um, and how did Christians in the late 19th century decide

00:59.775 --> 01:02.765
which kinds of those sufferings they would pay attention to,

01:03.705 --> 01:06.765
who suffering mattered, and how to respond to it?

01:06.825 --> 01:08.005
So those were some of the things

01:08.005 --> 01:11.125
that got me interested in researching this book

01:11.125 --> 01:13.565
that eventually led to Holy Humanitarians.

01:13.915 --> 01:17.845
Yeah, so I first started researching this questions of,

01:17.845 --> 01:20.245
Christians confronting various forms of suffering

01:20.245 --> 01:22.125
through missionary archives.

01:22.145 --> 01:26.325
So I was deep in the bells of Yale Divinity School archives

01:26.325 --> 01:27.365
and some missionary records,

01:27.545 --> 01:29.125
and I came across this reference

01:29.145 --> 01:31.965
to the Christian Herald Association,

01:31.965 --> 01:35.565
which was sponsoring an orphanage in Fuji China.

01:36.265 --> 01:38.685
Um, so I was thinking about suffering of children

01:38.945 --> 01:40.205
who were left parentless

01:40.225 --> 01:41.845
and thinking about missionaries on the field.

01:41.865 --> 01:42.925
And I thought, well, what is

01:42.925 --> 01:44.325
that thing the Christian Herald?

01:44.325 --> 01:45.485
Something I hadn't heard about?

01:46.545 --> 01:48.085
So, I started digging around

01:48.225 --> 01:49.445
and eventually I discovered

01:49.445 --> 01:52.605
that the Christian Herald was the world's most popular

01:52.835 --> 01:57.365
Christian newspaper from about 1890 to 1910.

01:57.465 --> 02:01.445
And that played a really major role in publicizing

02:01.545 --> 02:04.405
and responding to suffering across the United States

02:04.505 --> 02:06.405
and around the globe during its heyday,

02:06.935 --> 02:10.565
while also supporting various charitable organizations like

02:10.945 --> 02:14.525
the orphanage in eo, a Fresh Air Summer Home

02:14.525 --> 02:18.205
for children in the state of New York, an industrial school

02:18.265 --> 02:19.765
and post reconstruction air,

02:20.105 --> 02:22.645
the post reconstruction Air South,

02:22.705 --> 02:24.565
and most prominently, the Bowery Mission,

02:24.615 --> 02:26.685
which is a soup kitchen in New York City

02:26.685 --> 02:27.965
that still exists today.

02:28.185 --> 02:31.925
So, so I, this was what the newspaper was.

02:31.925 --> 02:33.765
So I started to look for copies of it,

02:33.865 --> 02:38.205
and I eventually discovered that the only surviving full run

02:38.305 --> 02:41.965
of the newspaper was housed in the Christian Harald Harald

02:41.965 --> 02:44.805
headquarters in New York City, which still existed.

02:44.905 --> 02:47.405
The newspaper was no longer being published at that time,

02:47.705 --> 02:50.565
but the Bowery Mission was still in operation.

02:50.745 --> 02:55.485
So I wrote to the, director of Outreach, James Macklin,

02:55.485 --> 02:57.565
and he invited me to come down and take a look.

02:57.745 --> 03:01.605
And, over the next several years, I spent hours

03:01.705 --> 03:03.165
and hours in the back room

03:03.185 --> 03:05.765
of the Christian Herald headquarters, getting to know

03:06.335 --> 03:09.085
James Macklin, the current president

03:09.085 --> 03:11.925
of the Bar mission today, James Winans,

03:12.145 --> 03:13.445
his colleague Julie Roma,

03:13.985 --> 03:16.925
and, ed Morgan, who was the president of that time

03:17.545 --> 03:18.645
at the, at the mission.

03:18.865 --> 03:20.805
And they really, I'm saying all this

03:20.805 --> 03:24.005
because it wasn't a traditional archival experience they

03:24.005 --> 03:26.525
had, I had to really gain their trust

03:26.745 --> 03:28.885
and they had to trust me to tell their story.

03:29.505 --> 03:32.445
Um, and they became really important conversation partners

03:32.515 --> 03:33.685
over the course of that time.

03:33.825 --> 03:37.165
I'm really grateful to them for allowing access to

03:37.875 --> 03:39.245
that treasured resource.

03:39.345 --> 03:41.165
And I think one of the things I'm most proud

03:41.165 --> 03:44.525
of about the project is the fact that,

03:44.795 --> 03:47.325
with the partnership of the Tufts Library,

03:47.495 --> 03:51.405
which I'm also very grateful for, we were able to digitize

03:51.405 --> 03:53.765
through internet archive, a full, most

03:53.825 --> 03:55.765
of the run of the newspaper.

03:56.305 --> 03:59.245
So now it exists for other scholars to be able to look at.

03:59.345 --> 04:01.125
So now if you go to internet archive

04:01.145 --> 04:02.445
and you see the Christian Herald,

04:02.445 --> 04:04.165
you can do your own research

04:04.185 --> 04:07.245
and there's, you know, so much, it's a fantastic research

04:07.305 --> 04:10.405
for thinking about religion in general.

04:10.785 --> 04:14.125
Humanitarianism in particular, during, from the 1880s,

04:14.125 --> 04:16.445
we have digitized up to about 1920,

04:17.225 --> 04:19.205
and we're still have a little piece left to go.

04:19.425 --> 04:22.165
So, besides that, you know, I spent a lot

04:22.165 --> 04:24.165
of time in archives, other archives

04:24.165 --> 04:26.205
of other missionary newspapers,

04:26.205 --> 04:29.565
looking at correspondence of the main figures,

04:30.605 --> 04:33.005
thinking about looking at competing organizations,

04:33.005 --> 04:35.165
which I may talk about at, at some point.

04:35.625 --> 04:37.805
The Red Cross was at the major competitor

04:38.025 --> 04:39.445
for the Christian Herald at the time.

04:40.105 --> 04:41.285
Um, so that's what I did.

04:41.555 --> 04:43.045
Yeah, so as I said,

04:43.045 --> 04:45.525
the Christian Herald really was the most influential

04:45.765 --> 04:49.805
religious newspaper in the US during its heyday from 1890

04:49.945 --> 04:51.165
to about 1910.

04:51.305 --> 04:55.725
And really key to that CE success was Louis Klos,

04:56.265 --> 04:58.525
who was an entrepreneurial philanthropist

04:58.585 --> 05:00.485
who purchased the paper in 1890

05:01.105 --> 05:04.125
and really worked to make it the nation's premier purveyor

05:04.125 --> 05:05.245
of humanitarian aid.

05:05.865 --> 05:08.125
And he partnered with this really

05:08.685 --> 05:11.885
charismatic preacher named Thomas dewitt Talmage,

05:11.945 --> 05:15.005
who is the pastor of the Brooklyn Tabernacle Church,

05:15.055 --> 05:17.125
which was at the time the United States

05:17.195 --> 05:18.685
largest congregation.

05:19.585 --> 05:22.845
So the two of them, really teamed up

05:22.905 --> 05:27.205
to combine biblical teachings about charity with

05:27.725 --> 05:30.125
emerging technologies of modern journalism.

05:30.305 --> 05:31.445
So things that we think of,

05:31.445 --> 05:33.365
sometimes we think about yellow journalism,

05:33.435 --> 05:34.525
it's right in that era.

05:35.145 --> 05:39.765
So they use gripping headlines, heartrending reporting,

05:40.605 --> 05:44.685
graphic photographs of suffering people to convince readers

05:44.685 --> 05:46.245
that aiding the affliction.

05:46.545 --> 05:48.325
The afflicted was really the obligation

05:48.385 --> 05:50.245
of every American citizen.

05:50.545 --> 05:54.725
So what they did was they solicited firsthand accounts

05:54.745 --> 05:56.885
of suffering and also photographs

05:56.985 --> 06:00.005
of calamities from this vast network of missionaries

06:00.715 --> 06:02.525
that they knew throughout the

06:02.525 --> 06:04.165
United States and around the world.

06:04.225 --> 06:05.965
So again, that connection to China is

06:05.965 --> 06:08.165
because they had a personal connection

06:08.165 --> 06:11.685
with those missionaries, and they, they were also,

06:13.085 --> 06:14.925
although Talmage himself was a member

06:15.165 --> 06:17.205
of the Christian reform denomination,

06:17.395 --> 06:19.285
they were very nondenominational.

06:19.345 --> 06:22.365
So the newspaper reached out was Presbyterians

06:22.475 --> 06:26.485
Episcopalians, Methodist Baptist, Dutch Reformed,

06:26.685 --> 06:28.525
I mean, any, they really had this idea

06:28.665 --> 06:31.005
of being broadly evangelical,

06:31.025 --> 06:35.085
and they used a small e it wasn't, we don't,

06:35.085 --> 06:37.005
we wanna be careful not to conflate the meaning of

06:37.005 --> 06:39.405
that term, and I'll get into a little bit more about

06:39.405 --> 06:40.925
what they meant by it at the time.

06:41.465 --> 06:43.405
So they just had these contexts,

06:43.505 --> 06:45.085
in all different denominations.

06:46.105 --> 06:48.765
And then they capitalized on sort

06:48.765 --> 06:50.285
of the interdenominational context

06:50.505 --> 06:52.365
and technological innovations.

06:52.395 --> 06:54.325
I've talked a little bit about journalism,

06:55.185 --> 06:58.085
but for example, this is also the era of the invention

06:58.105 --> 06:59.685
of the transatlantic telegraph.

06:59.785 --> 07:02.805
So that may possible the rapid transmission of news.

07:03.305 --> 07:06.285
So they could get a report about political conflict in

07:06.315 --> 07:09.725
Armenia from the missionaries over there right away,

07:09.825 --> 07:12.525
you know, as opposed to waiting for letters to come by boat.

07:13.185 --> 07:14.965
Um, similarly, the introduction

07:14.965 --> 07:19.045
of the Kodak portable camera in 1888 enabled eyewitnesses

07:19.045 --> 07:21.845
to document humanitarian catastrophes going on.

07:22.305 --> 07:24.445
And then there were printing processes

07:24.445 --> 07:25.925
that facilitated the reproduction

07:25.925 --> 07:27.525
of those images in the paper,

07:28.105 --> 07:31.205
and they were really at the cutting edge of that journalism.

07:31.345 --> 07:34.285
We don't hear about them often when we think about some

07:34.285 --> 07:36.405
of the other magnates in journalism at the time,

07:36.505 --> 07:40.485
but they really did, pioneer a lot of those efforts.

07:40.745 --> 07:42.645
And so what they hoped was

07:43.145 --> 07:47.285
so combining these firsthand accounts of disasters happening

07:47.285 --> 07:49.845
around the world, these vivid photography

07:50.575 --> 07:53.125
would both raise awareness of affliction

07:53.125 --> 07:55.125
and also sell newspapers, which it did.

07:55.185 --> 07:57.085
It was very successful at both things.

07:57.185 --> 07:59.605
So I think one of the things to keep in mind is that,

07:59.985 --> 08:02.245
you know, CoLab and Talmage are,

08:02.545 --> 08:06.325
really complicated individuals with who were very successful

08:06.385 --> 08:09.605
and, and clear about their ambitions for their newspaper.

08:10.185 --> 08:12.685
Um, and they combined sort of their religious faith

08:12.715 --> 08:16.045
with this, you know, very entrepreneurial spirit.

08:16.465 --> 08:19.245
Um, so they started out, like at first kind

08:19.245 --> 08:21.325
of chronicling their, these different catastrophes.

08:21.325 --> 08:24.045
So there was a big famine in Russia in 1892.

08:25.225 --> 08:29.805
Um, and then they very quickly turned from just saying like,

08:29.805 --> 08:33.085
Hey, there's all these things going on to making a case

08:33.115 --> 08:36.405
that their readers had a moral obligation to respond.

08:37.025 --> 08:40.965
And then actually using the newspaper as a fundraising tool,

08:41.625 --> 08:45.365
to collect money that then they would send abroad to,

08:45.665 --> 08:46.805
provide relief.

08:46.805 --> 08:48.725
So that's kind of a, a little sketch of

08:48.745 --> 08:50.245
how the newspaper got started,

08:50.505 --> 08:52.725
and I can, I'm happy to talk about, kind

08:52.725 --> 08:54.605
of continue the story of how they expanded

08:54.605 --> 08:57.365
Outward to different humanitarian com campaigns.

08:57.595 --> 09:00.645
Yeah, so I mean, as you say, there's a really broad array

09:00.665 --> 09:03.285
of, examples we could talk about.

09:03.505 --> 09:06.205
So the Bowery mission, the homelessness

09:06.255 --> 09:07.885
among New York City's unemployed,

09:07.945 --> 09:10.245
became the most enduring of their ministries.

09:10.865 --> 09:11.965
Um, I mentioned

09:11.965 --> 09:15.325
before the industrial school in the south, in South Carolina

09:15.325 --> 09:16.405
that, catered

09:16.405 --> 09:19.485
to formerly enslaved persons get providing education.

09:20.305 --> 09:23.205
And then they had, you know, beginning in Russia moving

09:23.205 --> 09:27.445
through Armenia to, Cuba, India, China,

09:27.675 --> 09:30.605
Scandinavia, Macedonia, Japan, Italy, Mexico,

09:31.585 --> 09:33.365
San Francisco.

09:34.035 --> 09:36.605
They had all kinds of humanitarian campaigns.

09:36.605 --> 09:37.845
So a disaster would happen.

09:38.395 --> 09:40.125
They would publicize it, they would say,

09:40.135 --> 09:43.245
we're opening the Christian Herald Famine Relief campaign,

09:43.955 --> 09:45.245
send your donations in.

09:45.245 --> 09:48.565
And then every week they would publish a list of people

09:48.625 --> 09:50.405
who had donated to the cause.

09:51.105 --> 09:54.365
And at a certain point they would close the, close the fund,

09:54.385 --> 09:56.565
and then they would send all the money to missionaries.

09:56.745 --> 09:59.765
So just for example, during the India famine campaign

09:59.765 --> 10:03.605
of 1900, which was their most successful campaign,

10:03.605 --> 10:04.805
and which also I may,

10:04.805 --> 10:07.045
if I can at one point hold up the cover of the book,

10:07.115 --> 10:10.165
it's the image of the cover of the book, is sort

10:10.165 --> 10:13.045
of celebrating this successful famine relief campaign.

10:13.795 --> 10:18.005
They collected over $1.2 million for food assistance,

10:19.045 --> 10:20.245
medicine and orphan care.

10:20.945 --> 10:23.845
Um, and all of those offerings, like I said, went directly

10:23.845 --> 10:26.605
to local volunteers, and those were usually missionaries.

10:26.745 --> 10:28.125
And India, it certainly was,

10:28.125 --> 10:29.965
they created a missionary council that

10:30.525 --> 10:33.525
included representatives from different denominations in

10:33.535 --> 10:38.165
India, and those volunteers doled out the money, right?

10:38.165 --> 10:39.925
They decided where it most needed to go.

10:40.185 --> 10:43.605
So the strategy was the missionaries, we've got this network

10:43.625 --> 10:45.045
of people already on the ground.

10:45.075 --> 10:47.725
They know the language, they know the culture,

10:48.395 --> 10:51.165
they're familiar with the needs and conditions, and

10:51.165 --> 10:54.965
therefore they can disseminate aid quickly and effectively.

10:55.185 --> 10:56.205
So in this way,

10:57.065 --> 11:00.365
to the Christian Herald really set itself apart deliberately

11:00.395 --> 11:03.965
from, emerging competitors like the American Red Cross.

11:04.985 --> 11:08.925
So in Armenia, there was a, at, at the Ottoman Empire,

11:08.925 --> 11:11.925
at a certain point was targeting Armenian Christians,

11:11.945 --> 11:13.805
and there was a massacres happening,

11:13.825 --> 11:15.965
and American missionaries had been there for

11:16.825 --> 11:19.085
almost a century, really decades at that point.

11:19.505 --> 11:21.805
So the Christian Herald sort of was in contact

11:22.725 --> 11:24.885
printing letters from missionaries explaining

11:24.885 --> 11:27.725
what was happening, sending relief to the missionaries to

11:28.355 --> 11:30.045
provide for people on the ground.

11:30.465 --> 11:34.285
The American Red Cross sent over American aid workers,

11:35.135 --> 11:37.805
Clara Barton herself went, and it was really challenging

11:37.805 --> 11:41.245
because she didn't know the language, she had no idea

11:41.275 --> 11:42.565
what the politics were.

11:43.305 --> 11:44.965
And so the Christian Herald was sort

11:44.965 --> 11:46.725
of setting itself up saying, Hey, you know,

11:46.775 --> 11:49.805
we've got a network and this is how age should be done.

11:49.945 --> 11:52.125
At the same time, early on,

11:52.265 --> 11:55.365
Claire Barton was a notoriously poor record keeper,

11:56.025 --> 11:57.725
and the Christian Herald made a point

11:57.745 --> 12:00.925
of publishing an audited account of its like,

12:00.925 --> 12:02.365
here's all the money we received,

12:02.825 --> 12:04.085
here's how we were spent it.

12:04.085 --> 12:06.005
And they publish a balance sheet, you know,

12:06.005 --> 12:07.325
after the close of the campaign

12:07.865 --> 12:09.805
and really tried to say, you know, we are,

12:10.145 --> 12:12.845
we should be entrusted with, I mean, at this time,

12:12.875 --> 12:16.325
it's important to remember there is no infrastructure at the

12:16.325 --> 12:18.485
federal level for providing aid.

12:18.485 --> 12:21.125
There's no U-S-A-I-D, there's no agencies

12:21.125 --> 12:22.445
that are officially doing this.

12:23.185 --> 12:26.125
So the Christian Herald is trying to say,

12:27.185 --> 12:29.125
we should be at the forefront of this

12:29.185 --> 12:30.605
for the American Nation.

12:31.545 --> 12:35.565
And they were arguing as well that having an explicitly

12:36.205 --> 12:39.565
religious vision for aid was something important

12:39.715 --> 12:43.125
that would identify the United States as a different kind

12:43.225 --> 12:46.405
of world power than other world powers.

12:46.405 --> 12:48.965
So they sort of had this idea that we're not going to be

12:49.725 --> 12:52.645
imperialists like the British, right.

12:52.645 --> 12:54.285
We're not gonna establish an empire.

12:54.375 --> 12:56.365
We're gonna establish a moral empire,

12:56.505 --> 12:58.965
and that's gonna be pervade through Christian charity.

12:59.305 --> 13:02.725
So they're really quite successful.

13:02.745 --> 13:06.005
By the time Lops died in 1910,

13:06.685 --> 13:09.805
subscribers have donated over $3.3 million

13:10.345 --> 13:13.245
to both domestic and international crises.

13:13.585 --> 13:16.485
And that's about in today's good dollars.

13:16.545 --> 13:20.725
So 2024, it's about a hundred million dollars in aid.

13:20.905 --> 13:23.885
And really the Red Cross by, at that exact moment,

13:24.185 --> 13:27.965
no other relief organization came remotely close to

13:28.795 --> 13:30.525
that fundraising capacity

13:30.665 --> 13:34.205
or sort of popular concern for suffering.

13:34.345 --> 13:38.205
So, I can talk a little bit more about why I think,

13:38.205 --> 13:39.325
do I have a couple more minutes

13:39.345 --> 13:41.205
to say why I think they were so successful?

13:41.315 --> 13:43.365
Yeah. Well, I mean, definitely, I mean,

13:43.365 --> 13:45.085
and Lops had lots of critics.

13:45.115 --> 13:47.365
There's a, I mean, part of the book

13:47.365 --> 13:50.285
that I love is just the absolute, like take down fight

13:50.285 --> 13:51.285
between himself

13:51.285 --> 13:54.525
and Clara Barton, who, I mean, she, he thought she was,

13:54.625 --> 13:56.085
you know, egotistical

13:56.225 --> 13:57.685
and, you know,

13:57.985 --> 14:00.285
not a poor poorly managing her organization.

14:00.465 --> 14:04.805
And she thought he was, a real charlatan, right?

14:04.805 --> 14:06.365
That he was. And so they really,

14:06.825 --> 14:08.485
really disagreed with one another.

14:09.265 --> 14:12.005
And, but he was a very savvy businessman.

14:12.265 --> 14:15.805
Um, so, but he also had a message, I mean, think Klos

14:15.805 --> 14:18.005
and Talmage had this message, and it was multi-pronged.

14:18.065 --> 14:22.725
So one part of it was that philanthropy is something

14:22.725 --> 14:24.885
that every American should be involved in, right?

14:24.885 --> 14:27.085
This wasn't an elite practice.

14:27.085 --> 14:29.445
And at some point, I'll talk about sort of the contrast

14:29.445 --> 14:31.485
between the Christian Herald

14:31.505 --> 14:33.485
and say the rise of,

14:34.425 --> 14:37.885
the big Carnegie Rockefeller sort of wealthy family.

14:37.985 --> 14:40.845
So that model of philanthropy, coop

14:40.845 --> 14:41.925
and Alman said, you know what?

14:41.925 --> 14:44.005
Every person, even if you have a nickel

14:44.025 --> 14:46.405
or a dime, that's gonna make a difference,

14:46.405 --> 14:47.685
that can buy a loaf of bread.

14:47.945 --> 14:49.845
And they actually would publicize,

14:49.845 --> 14:52.125
like Sunday school classes would send in,

14:52.295 --> 14:53.645
would like take collections,

14:53.705 --> 14:56.485
and kids would go without dinner for a week

14:56.505 --> 14:58.485
and send the money that they're gonna spend on dinner

14:58.505 --> 14:59.525
to the Christian Herald.

14:59.525 --> 15:03.405
And so this was this sort of popular democratizing thing

15:03.755 --> 15:04.765
that he said,

15:04.985 --> 15:08.405
and they said, should be characteristic of Americans, like,

15:08.405 --> 15:11.045
this is how Americans were gonna stand out in the world.

15:11.945 --> 15:14.645
Um, and they also, like, the part

15:14.645 --> 15:16.485
of the religious dimension is I mentioned

15:16.485 --> 15:17.965
before that they are trying

15:18.025 --> 15:21.965
to build bridges across various denominations.

15:22.665 --> 15:25.445
So the 1880s and nineties is when we're just starting

15:25.445 --> 15:28.285
to see in the United States debates

15:28.405 --> 15:31.485
among American Protestants about how to interpret the Bible.

15:32.225 --> 15:36.765
Um, we are seeing social prejudices with the, fall

15:36.765 --> 15:38.285
of reconstruction in the South,

15:38.345 --> 15:40.525
and sort of an attempt to overcome the

15:40.525 --> 15:41.925
divisiveness of the Civil War.

15:42.505 --> 15:44.645
Um, disagreements about race.

15:44.735 --> 15:48.245
We're seeing debates about immigration to the United States,

15:48.425 --> 15:51.005
particularly from Asia,

15:51.025 --> 15:53.605
but also Russia, Eastern Europe.

15:54.425 --> 15:57.245
Um, so there's a lot of antagonism

15:57.345 --> 15:59.605
and cultural conflicts in the American public,

15:59.865 --> 16:04.845
and they are arguing that we can get past debates about all

16:04.965 --> 16:08.205
of these things, especially theology, if we just focus on

16:08.205 --> 16:09.485
what Americans have in common

16:09.905 --> 16:11.405
and what Americans have in common.

16:11.505 --> 16:12.885
And by Americans at that time,

16:12.885 --> 16:14.925
they made American Protestants mostly.

16:16.025 --> 16:18.845
We can not worry about, you know, that one of the,

16:18.845 --> 16:20.445
my bet the best lines that to,

16:20.585 --> 16:22.085
in the book is like, who cares?

16:22.085 --> 16:25.325
Who wrote the penit took the first five books of the Bible?

16:25.795 --> 16:27.125
Like, let's not worry about that,

16:27.185 --> 16:28.445
but let's worry about that.

16:28.445 --> 16:30.005
We're following Jesus' command

16:30.005 --> 16:31.245
to love your neighbor as yourself.

16:31.245 --> 16:32.845
Like certainly that's the golden rule.

16:33.345 --> 16:34.485
We can all agree on it.

16:34.905 --> 16:36.885
So that was sort of one thing that they did.

16:37.865 --> 16:39.685
Um, and in order to do that, they're like,

16:39.685 --> 16:42.325
we're not gonna talk about all these controversial subjects

16:42.445 --> 16:45.285
in the newspaper, so we're not gonna publicize if you know

16:45.385 --> 16:48.485
so and so in the Presbyterian denomination is kicked out

16:48.485 --> 16:51.565
for being a heretic for how he interprets the Bible.

16:52.225 --> 16:56.005
Um, and also, we're not gonna publicize, you know,

16:56.005 --> 16:57.325
we're not gonna be political, we're not,

16:57.325 --> 17:01.445
they did talk about they would, have coverage

17:01.445 --> 17:03.605
of presidential candidates and that sort of thing,

17:03.605 --> 17:04.805
but they would do both sides.

17:05.865 --> 17:08.245
Um, and although their most,

17:08.295 --> 17:10.725
their target audience is white Protestants,

17:10.755 --> 17:13.645
they also were somewhat ecumenical.

17:14.025 --> 17:15.485
Um, they took pains

17:15.485 --> 17:17.805
to include stories about African American churches

17:18.185 --> 17:19.325
and charities.

17:19.945 --> 17:21.485
Um, they reported on the plight

17:21.485 --> 17:24.245
of Native Americans at the time, which is pretty unique

17:24.305 --> 17:25.685
for American Protestants.

17:26.265 --> 17:28.805
Um, they also were very pro-immigration

17:28.905 --> 17:31.045
and anti the Chinese Exclusion Act

17:31.045 --> 17:33.245
or the Asian Exclusion Act that were, so,

17:33.245 --> 17:36.405
they were very welcoming towards Asian immigrants.

17:37.305 --> 17:40.965
Um, they highlight the work of Jewish philanthropists,

17:41.305 --> 17:44.365
and they actually built some bridges with Catholics

17:44.385 --> 17:47.085
and all of that at a time when lots

17:47.085 --> 17:49.645
of Protestant leaders were supporting racial segregation,

17:49.855 --> 17:51.525
expressing antisemitism

17:52.225 --> 17:53.725
and accusing the pope of trying

17:53.725 --> 17:55.725
to take over the United States with these, you know,

17:55.725 --> 17:56.845
conspiracy theories.

17:57.035 --> 17:58.605
Like this was somewhat noteworthy

17:58.635 --> 18:02.005
that they did have this very big tent kind of attitude.

18:02.465 --> 18:06.605
Um, and then another sort of theology point,

18:06.785 --> 18:09.605
and this can be my last one if I'm running outta time on

18:09.605 --> 18:13.605
this question, was that, by sort of publicizing all

18:13.605 --> 18:16.285
of these events all around the world, they,

18:16.305 --> 18:18.445
so they had on one hand, like g that our,

18:18.445 --> 18:19.725
we love our neighbors ourselves.

18:19.725 --> 18:23.285
That's a key text. Another key text is,

18:23.435 --> 18:27.685
acts 17 from the New Testament, God has made one blood

18:27.745 --> 18:30.045
of one blood all nations of men

18:30.145 --> 18:31.725
or of human beings, we would say now.

18:32.385 --> 18:35.365
And that was, you know, charity had to be worldwide.

18:35.425 --> 18:38.805
It didn't matter about race, class or nationality.

18:38.905 --> 18:41.645
So they also regularly quoted, story

18:41.645 --> 18:45.525
of the Good Samaritan who crossed racial and ethnic lines

18:45.745 --> 18:48.725
and saying, we can't just be concerned, we can't be tribal.

18:49.305 --> 18:51.845
We can't just be concerned about our own denomination

18:51.865 --> 18:55.605
or our own region, but we have to extend mercy

18:56.105 --> 18:57.925
and charity around the world.

18:58.065 --> 18:59.365
So, and this is where maybe,

18:59.645 --> 19:01.365
I don't know if we'll be able to see this too.

19:01.395 --> 19:03.965
Well, there's, I have

19:03.965 --> 19:05.565
to un blur my background for a second.

19:05.715 --> 19:06.765
Yeah, there it is.

19:06.825 --> 19:09.565
So the cover of the Christian Herald is from,

19:10.075 --> 19:13.645
this is a photograph from their 1900 newspaper cover

19:13.645 --> 19:17.285
that shows the success of the India Famine campaign.

19:17.285 --> 19:21.125
And you can see how they're, representing here a lot

19:21.125 --> 19:22.245
of their different efforts.

19:22.345 --> 19:24.045
So there's a veiled woman here,

19:24.565 --> 19:26.045
probably from the Armenian campaign.

19:26.045 --> 19:29.005
There's the Indian Famine Relief here.

19:29.425 --> 19:32.725
Um, this is the Bowery mission represented here,

19:33.625 --> 19:35.605
and all of this here again, this is the

19:36.165 --> 19:37.645
children's home being represented.

19:38.545 --> 19:41.725
So, and it's titled America The Almanar of the World.

19:42.145 --> 19:43.725
And this is a really, I mean,

19:43.765 --> 19:45.125
I can say more about this later as well,

19:45.125 --> 19:46.645
it's a really complicated image,

19:46.785 --> 19:49.165
but it shows that they felt

19:49.955 --> 19:53.605
that the United States was this redeemer nation

19:53.835 --> 19:55.405
that possessed this unique power

19:55.625 --> 19:59.285
and resources to help the need and oppressed.

19:59.285 --> 20:01.245
So it's a very, when I show it to my students, they're like,

20:01.245 --> 20:03.925
that's the, you know, genesis of the white savior image.

20:04.025 --> 20:05.085
I'm like, yes, it is.

20:05.145 --> 20:07.405
In some ways I don't wanna claim that that's the start,

20:07.405 --> 20:10.645
but that's very much like, let's go out into the world not

20:10.645 --> 20:11.845
through an imperial frame

20:11.985 --> 20:14.365
or if the imperial frame is going to be through charity.

20:14.985 --> 20:18.765
Um, that gets a little complicated when they get involved.

20:18.865 --> 20:22.285
And the America does become an imperial power, when it,

20:22.285 --> 20:24.285
gets involved in the Philippine war.

20:25.025 --> 20:28.245
And there they start to argue, you see a pivot where like,

20:28.355 --> 20:31.285
well, actually, you know, if war is being done to

20:31.925 --> 20:35.005
liberate oppressed peoples elsewhere, it can be a form

20:35.005 --> 20:36.645
of humanitarianism too.

20:37.465 --> 20:40.725
Um, and that's one place where we start to get into tensions

20:40.725 --> 20:43.405
where critics start to say, wait a second.

20:43.515 --> 20:46.605
Like, is that really, like, who, who who is saying

20:46.625 --> 20:47.885
who needs to be liberated?

20:48.585 --> 20:52.445
Um, is this kind of hierarchical image really representing

20:52.985 --> 20:54.125
the kingdom of God?

20:54.315 --> 20:57.325
That that is saying all nations of men are, you know,

20:57.325 --> 21:00.245
in Jesus Christ, every, there's neither Jew nor Greek slave,

21:00.265 --> 21:01.725
nor free male nor female.

21:01.825 --> 21:04.205
So now I'm speaking from the voice of many

21:04.205 --> 21:07.045
of the missionaries on the ground who felt that some

21:07.045 --> 21:09.245
of the Christian Herald's perspective

21:09.905 --> 21:11.565
was somewhat paternalistic, right.

21:11.625 --> 21:13.845
And imperialistic in its own way. Yeah.

21:13.945 --> 21:15.525
So there's a couple different factors

21:15.525 --> 21:16.805
that go into the decline.

21:16.885 --> 21:20.085
I mean, one is, as I just, the solidarity

21:20.085 --> 21:22.205
that they built becomes increasingly

21:22.205 --> 21:23.685
difficult to maintain, right?

21:23.725 --> 21:26.125
Especially after cops dies in 1910.

21:26.305 --> 21:30.605
So as, tensions mount within Protestantism around

21:31.125 --> 21:33.685
biblical interpretations, we've got the beginnings

21:33.685 --> 21:36.085
of debates between what come, come

21:36.085 --> 21:37.765
to be called fundamentalist Christians

21:37.825 --> 21:39.005
and modernist Christians.

21:39.835 --> 21:43.885
It's hard for the Christian Herald to ignore that, right?

21:44.065 --> 21:46.525
And then over time, eventually those groups,

21:46.595 --> 21:47.605
both fundamentalists

21:47.605 --> 21:50.405
and modernists begin to create their own newspapers.

21:50.545 --> 21:53.685
So, the modernists create the Christian century.

21:54.295 --> 21:57.325
Eventually by the 1940s, the evangelicals,

21:57.345 --> 22:00.085
the fundamentalists who become then new evangelicals,

22:00.105 --> 22:03.405
so different worth use of the term than the way K

22:03.505 --> 22:06.325
and Talmage were using it, create Christianity today.

22:07.185 --> 22:09.725
Um, and so market share goes down, right?

22:09.725 --> 22:11.645
That's one, issue.

22:11.705 --> 22:14.485
But even prior to that, there are a series of things.

22:14.625 --> 22:17.725
So the American red, so there's fractures

22:17.725 --> 22:20.165
with American presentism that I just described.

22:20.745 --> 22:23.045
Um, there's the growth of the US state.

22:23.185 --> 22:27.045
So the, the federal government does begin to create at,

22:27.145 --> 22:29.085
in partnership with the Red Cross Act,

22:29.485 --> 22:33.445
actually a federal structure for overseas disaster relief.

22:33.985 --> 22:36.085
And that starts to happen at the turn of the century

22:36.185 --> 22:37.885
and into, and by World War I,

22:38.225 --> 22:41.485
the Red Cross is really a quasi-governmental agency.

22:42.185 --> 22:43.845
Um, and in part it wins out

22:43.845 --> 22:47.325
because it does have a much more secular message, right?

22:47.325 --> 22:49.805
There's, it's not sort of wetting its message

22:49.805 --> 22:53.605
with this very explicitly biblical, campaign.

22:54.545 --> 22:58.885
By the 1930s, we have the expansion of the welfare state.

22:59.065 --> 23:01.765
So there's, you know, that in the US there's infrastructure

23:01.815 --> 23:04.325
being put in place to care for people

23:04.345 --> 23:05.365
who are falling through.

23:05.455 --> 23:06.645
There is a safety net

23:06.645 --> 23:08.845
where there wasn't in the 1880s and nineties.

23:09.625 --> 23:12.125
We also have the professionalization of social work.

23:12.225 --> 23:13.805
So social work, and, you know,

23:13.845 --> 23:16.725
philanthropy becomes its own aid.

23:16.725 --> 23:19.205
They're the creation of, you know, professional schools.

23:19.305 --> 23:21.285
You can become trained as a social worker.

23:21.385 --> 23:23.645
And that wasn't the case in the eighties and nineties.

23:24.545 --> 23:26.365
Um, and then finally you've got the rise

23:26.365 --> 23:29.925
of these massive family foundations, the Carnegies

23:29.925 --> 23:31.085
and the Rockefellers, right?

23:31.085 --> 23:32.085
Really eclipse

23:32.865 --> 23:35.525
and diminish the Christian Herald stature

23:35.625 --> 23:36.885
as a relief agency.

23:37.065 --> 23:38.165
So,

23:38.225 --> 23:39.845
and that's a point it might be worth

23:39.885 --> 23:41.325
dwelling on a little bit.

23:41.625 --> 23:45.085
Um, I've talked about sort of this sense that,

23:46.365 --> 23:47.925
Talmage and CLOs had that you have

23:47.925 --> 23:49.805
to aid anyone who needs help, right?

23:49.825 --> 23:51.045
And they did both. I mean,

23:51.235 --> 23:53.445
they were really about emergency relief.

23:54.305 --> 23:57.765
Um, and at the same time they did lobby

23:57.945 --> 24:00.005
for broader structural solutions as well,

24:00.145 --> 24:02.245
but they start to get really critiqued.

24:02.245 --> 24:05.765
So one of the signature, the surviving entity

24:05.765 --> 24:07.405
of the Christian Herald today is really the

24:07.405 --> 24:08.645
Bowery mission in New York City.

24:09.265 --> 24:13.845
Um, that, enterprise, as long as, as well as other sort

24:13.845 --> 24:15.125
of soup kitchens in New York,

24:15.125 --> 24:18.965
came under blistering attack in the early 20th century by

24:19.735 --> 24:22.285
proponents of what was called scientific charity.

24:23.325 --> 24:25.465
So one of the leaders of that movement was

24:26.085 --> 24:28.705
the industrial magnate, Andrew Carnegie, right?

24:28.805 --> 24:33.505
And Carnegie, in his view, if wealth came

24:33.505 --> 24:35.305
to the worthy, like if you worked hard,

24:35.685 --> 24:39.545
if you saved responsibly, if you lived a virtuous life,

24:40.445 --> 24:41.465
you would become wealthy.

24:42.735 --> 24:47.065
Therefore, if you were poor, that meant that you were lazy,

24:47.885 --> 24:49.465
irresponsible

24:49.805 --> 24:52.265
and engaging in some kind of immoral,

24:52.315 --> 24:53.985
maybe usually drunken behavior.

24:54.425 --> 24:56.545
I mean, maybe there were some times where, you know,

24:56.545 --> 24:58.505
there was some kind of misfortune, but by,

24:58.505 --> 25:00.105
and by, like, that was the equation.

25:00.445 --> 25:04.785
So the job of philanthropists was to work scientifically.

25:05.055 --> 25:08.705
That was the term, to figure out who deserved help.

25:08.775 --> 25:11.345
Like the deserving poor, maybe those who were trying

25:11.345 --> 25:13.025
to pull themselves up by their bootstraps,

25:13.025 --> 25:14.745
or maybe they had a misfortune,

25:15.565 --> 25:18.305
and the derelicts who lived off free handouts, right?

25:18.325 --> 25:20.985
And so we still have this in our culture, right?

25:20.985 --> 25:24.145
There's still debates about who really deserves help.

25:24.965 --> 25:27.145
So Carnegie and his,

25:27.525 --> 25:30.145
allies in the San Scientific Charity movement said,

25:30.245 --> 25:32.345
if you're gonna run a soup kitchen like the Barry Mission,

25:32.345 --> 25:33.985
you're just perpetuating the problem.

25:34.175 --> 25:37.905
Like you are, enabling people to live off the doll.

25:37.925 --> 25:41.705
And instead you should, sort of go out

25:41.725 --> 25:42.865
and register people,

25:43.205 --> 25:45.105
and you figure out not give aid to anybody

25:45.165 --> 25:47.665
who doesn't really work for it and deserve it.

25:48.365 --> 25:52.265
And you should establish institutions to help people sort

25:52.265 --> 25:53.425
of work their way up.

25:53.605 --> 25:54.945
So libraries,

25:54.945 --> 25:57.145
we've got the Carnegie Library in New York, right?

25:57.155 --> 26:00.345
We've got, educational institutions,

26:01.005 --> 26:02.705
art galleries, public parks.

26:02.705 --> 26:04.545
So it was sort of, you give people the tools

26:04.685 --> 26:06.665
to learn how to help themselves.

26:07.725 --> 26:10.425
So as this kind of idea gains authority,

26:11.555 --> 26:14.065
ction Talmage are basically acknowledge like, okay,

26:14.065 --> 26:15.585
there are some scientific methods

26:15.655 --> 26:19.185
that maybe could help us improve efficiency in philanthropy,

26:19.285 --> 26:22.065
but they really repudiated the claim

26:22.095 --> 26:24.425
that charity led to delinquency.

26:24.425 --> 26:28.385
And I think this has to do in part with, sort of being,

26:28.475 --> 26:30.865
again, like closer to the ground,

26:31.085 --> 26:33.025
and involved in this charitable work.

26:33.885 --> 26:36.225
So rather than blaming the needy

26:36.225 --> 26:39.825
or unemployed for their situation, K

26:39.965 --> 26:41.825
and Talmage both, like, especially in

26:41.825 --> 26:44.885
around the eight later 1890s turn of the 20th century,

26:45.705 --> 26:48.365
really tried to publish articles saying, we've gotta get

26:48.365 --> 26:49.565
to the root of the problem.

26:49.985 --> 26:51.645
And what would we call today?

26:51.645 --> 26:52.925
They didn't use this language,

26:52.945 --> 26:54.565
but we would say they started

26:54.585 --> 26:57.565
to recognize the structural elements of inequality, right?

26:57.625 --> 26:58.845
And to,

26:59.145 --> 27:01.925
and they did say, I mean, they were always,

27:02.355 --> 27:05.605
they would never say this directly about Carnegie.

27:05.605 --> 27:08.325
They did feature him, you know, in their newspaper

27:08.385 --> 27:09.725
as a, you know, philanthropist.

27:09.825 --> 27:13.445
But they did say things like, if, if anybody was

27:13.445 --> 27:15.685
to be accounta held accountable for suffering,

27:16.305 --> 27:18.205
it was the wealthy industrialists

27:18.205 --> 27:21.005
who weren't paying a fair wage,

27:21.065 --> 27:23.085
who were inflating prices, who were

27:23.725 --> 27:26.565
amassing colossal fortunes on the backs of their workers,

27:27.055 --> 27:29.685
extracting resources from colonized peoples.

27:30.025 --> 27:34.325
So they said, you know, in, again, in somewhat

27:34.325 --> 27:38.325
of a diplomatic way, most of the time, that instead of

27:38.845 --> 27:41.405
building libraries, I mean, well, colleges, libraries, all

27:41.405 --> 27:43.525
that's great, but what really need to happen is

27:43.525 --> 27:46.925
that Carnegie should offer higher salaries, explain,

27:47.065 --> 27:50.605
expand employment opportunities, support legislation

27:50.705 --> 27:52.765
to ensure fair labor and housing conditions.

27:53.585 --> 27:57.645
Um, and one of their, in the 19 early 20th century,

27:58.005 --> 28:01.085
actually, so the early 19 hundreds, one of their,

28:01.565 --> 28:04.565
featured authors was a minister named Charles Sheldon.

28:05.265 --> 28:08.405
Um, Charles Sheldon is famous today for the acronym

28:08.595 --> 28:11.925
what ww JD what would Jesus do?

28:12.745 --> 28:17.685
Um, and he published a serial novel in the pages

28:17.685 --> 28:20.325
that Christian Herald, called Christian Socialism.

28:20.865 --> 28:25.125
And he basically argued for what a sort of a program of,

28:25.505 --> 28:30.005
pri of making, you know, private, like common goods,

28:30.005 --> 28:32.605
common ownership of public utilities, that sort of thing,

28:33.165 --> 28:36.165
redistributing wealth, like it really was a,

28:36.365 --> 28:38.325
a socialistic vision of the future.

28:38.665 --> 28:41.765
And that's partly what Talmage were behind as well.

28:42.585 --> 28:44.165
So a really different, but,

28:44.265 --> 28:46.125
but in the end, like that, just that vision

28:46.305 --> 28:48.805
as we know in the United States, does not win out.

28:49.385 --> 28:53.405
Um, it is the vision of the Carnegies and the Rockefellers,

28:53.505 --> 28:56.245
and eventually they, they just can't compete with

28:56.945 --> 28:59.805
the massive fortunes that are put together

28:59.825 --> 29:02.485
and the family foundations that are set up to preserve

29:02.485 --> 29:03.725
that generational wealth.

29:04.585 --> 29:07.605
And they, they just can't compete in the marketplace either

29:07.625 --> 29:09.085
of sort of religious newspapers

29:09.145 --> 29:11.245
or of philanthropic foundations.

29:11.665 --> 29:14.045
And so they, they sort of pull back,

29:14.045 --> 29:15.925
they start focusing the paper.

29:16.005 --> 29:17.805
I mean, KLO dies, Talmage died earlier.

29:18.025 --> 29:22.525
So by like the time of World War One,

29:22.985 --> 29:25.245
the new editors of the paper decide they're gonna

29:25.925 --> 29:28.325
refocus the paper on more religious themes,

29:28.665 --> 29:31.125
and they're gonna kind of divest themselves of most

29:31.125 --> 29:33.325
of its charitable enterprise, with the exception

29:33.325 --> 29:34.845
of the Bowery Mission.

29:35.185 --> 29:36.325
And the, it's called,

29:36.425 --> 29:38.125
it was called Mont Lawn Children's Camp.

29:38.145 --> 29:41.845
And it exists today still in some children's programs

29:41.845 --> 29:43.285
that the Barry Mission runs.

29:44.025 --> 29:47.965
Um, they kept on publishing the paper until about the 1990s,

29:47.985 --> 29:49.285
and then they closed it down.

29:49.425 --> 29:52.485
And now the, it really, if you go online looking

29:52.505 --> 29:54.005
for the Christian Herald Association,

29:54.005 --> 29:55.005
you'll find the Barry Mission

29:55.265 --> 29:56.925
and, they're still going strong.

29:57.395 --> 30:01.005
Yeah. So I think there's, the book has a lot

30:01.025 --> 30:03.845
to teach us about the topics of humanitarianism,

30:03.905 --> 30:07.365
and I talk about this, mostly in the epilogue.

30:08.385 --> 30:11.365
So I mean, I'll I'll say kind of in two, two things.

30:11.625 --> 30:13.885
One is, although, you know, nobody's heard

30:13.885 --> 30:15.205
of the Christian Herald today, right?

30:15.445 --> 30:17.045
I mean, unless you've read my book, maybe

30:17.045 --> 30:19.405
unless you've been to the Bar Mission, everybody's heard

30:19.405 --> 30:20.805
of the Rockefeller Foundation,

30:20.925 --> 30:22.565
Carnegie the American Red Cross,

30:23.465 --> 30:25.245
and yet I really do believe

30:25.245 --> 30:27.445
that the Christian Herald's relief campaigns

30:27.515 --> 30:28.885
left a lasting mark.

30:29.245 --> 30:32.325
I think, the cover that I showed

30:32.325 --> 30:36.525
before with the United States as this kind of savior alman

30:36.525 --> 30:40.525
or of all nations affected the way humanitarian relief

30:40.805 --> 30:42.045
happened even for the Red Cross.

30:42.145 --> 30:44.685
So in the book, I have an image of the Red Cross in,

30:44.705 --> 30:47.405
in World War i's very similar sort

30:47.405 --> 30:48.845
of presenting the United States,

30:49.145 --> 30:52.125
having this divinely ordained responsibility to rescue

30:52.985 --> 30:55.885
the afflicted and the United States throughout the 20th

30:55.885 --> 30:59.245
century, really engaged in a lot of humanitarian

30:59.765 --> 31:03.005
interventions, you know, often staged as war, right?

31:03.145 --> 31:05.325
As well, just like it was in the Philippines.

31:05.505 --> 31:08.845
And, you know, if we were to catalog a lot, those,

31:08.845 --> 31:12.005
like many of those relief efforts have saved lives.

31:12.945 --> 31:14.965
Um, there's also been critics

31:15.185 --> 31:18.005
of those aid agents, agencies, and efforts.

31:18.065 --> 31:20.205
So my own colleague at Tufts, Alex Deval

31:20.705 --> 31:23.885
and others have talked about how disaster remediation

31:23.985 --> 31:27.445
and development activities have often fueled corruption

31:27.445 --> 31:30.005
and host countries exacerbated poverty,

31:31.125 --> 31:32.885
bolstered authoritarian regimes.

31:33.625 --> 31:35.965
So there's that, to think about.

31:35.995 --> 31:37.685
There's also the use of images.

31:37.885 --> 31:40.605
I mean, the Christian Herald really was, I do make a case

31:40.605 --> 31:44.805
that they're really the pioneer of using what gets called,

31:44.905 --> 31:48.685
you know, famine porn, really just these images

31:48.685 --> 31:49.885
of people in pain

31:50.505 --> 31:53.325
and aid agencies have relied on those kind kinds

31:53.325 --> 31:54.525
of images up to the present.

31:54.805 --> 31:57.685
I mean, I think, we can think about, you know,

31:57.685 --> 32:01.085
recent IMA images in the US of, border crossers,

32:01.085 --> 32:02.965
people coming from Mexico into the US

32:03.185 --> 32:05.205
and their shock value, right?

32:05.225 --> 32:08.165
And so there too, I think ethicists really warn about the

32:08.165 --> 32:10.605
implications of that, those kind of images.

32:11.235 --> 32:15.005
They're effective, but they reinforce inequalities between

32:15.925 --> 32:18.125
privileged donors and relief recipients

32:18.145 --> 32:22.245
and sort of reproduce the structural, nature of that

32:22.315 --> 32:24.565
that requires us to have charity in the first place.

32:24.745 --> 32:27.405
So there's that to think about we

32:27.405 --> 32:29.445
with thinking about the Christian Herald, what can we

32:30.135 --> 32:32.405
learn from the blind spots, right,

32:32.405 --> 32:33.765
that the Christian Herald had?

32:33.865 --> 32:36.325
And what are the blind spots that we still have?

32:36.425 --> 32:38.405
So I think I chose that image for the cover

32:39.435 --> 32:42.405
because it's easy to judge that era, right?

32:42.405 --> 32:45.965
And say, look at how, you know, paternalistic they were.

32:46.145 --> 32:49.645
But we also can see that, you know, the ongoing legacy of

32:49.645 --> 32:52.485
that, I think in our own relief efforts today.

32:53.545 --> 32:57.365
On the other hand, I think the newspaper's arguments

32:57.505 --> 33:01.045
for extending compassion beyond national borders

33:01.045 --> 33:03.365
and social barriers remain really relevant.

33:03.425 --> 33:07.285
So I've already alluded to debates we have today in the US

33:07.345 --> 33:09.805
and really around the world about poverty assistance,

33:10.035 --> 33:12.645
immigration, global inequality,

33:13.305 --> 33:15.485
how do we create a justice society?

33:15.985 --> 33:19.525
Um, so some of the questions I talked about with my friends

33:19.555 --> 33:21.285
that I made at the Christian Herald is,

33:21.355 --> 33:23.325
does charity create dependency?

33:23.905 --> 33:27.445
Um, who gets to help from philanthropist,

33:27.975 --> 33:29.525
which disaster makes the news?

33:29.545 --> 33:30.805
We have this right now. I mean,

33:30.805 --> 33:33.085
what's happening in in Ethiopia, right?

33:33.225 --> 33:35.845
And, versus,

33:36.025 --> 33:38.925
and things that are getting coverage, things that don't,

33:39.425 --> 33:42.325
is what do we do about i meeting emergency needs versus

33:42.385 --> 33:44.165
trying to invest in efforts

33:44.265 --> 33:46.365
to alleviate structural inequality?

33:47.065 --> 33:48.165
Um, how should a,

33:48.345 --> 33:50.085
an organization like the Barry mission today,

33:50.085 --> 33:51.845
like should they be trying to do both

33:52.065 --> 33:53.805
or should they concentrate on one?

33:54.625 --> 33:57.605
Um, how can we encourage empathy for people

33:57.625 --> 34:01.525
who are suffering without reinforcing these inequalities,

34:01.745 --> 34:04.325
social disparities, racial discrimination,

34:04.385 --> 34:07.125
gender bias, nationalist hierarchies?

34:07.125 --> 34:11.485
So I think my hope is that in reading this book, people

34:11.485 --> 34:14.325
who are in trying to make the world a better place will

34:15.445 --> 34:17.445
recognize some of the things that get, that, you know,

34:17.515 --> 34:21.325
that can get involved when you start asking those questions.

34:21.745 --> 34:25.205
Um, and maybe there's something in what, what the collapse

34:25.205 --> 34:28.285
and Talmage were saying that we might, learn from.

34:28.585 --> 34:32.525
So I, I wonder if clap to claim that true Christianity must,

34:32.785 --> 34:35.645
he said is can't be limited to our own tribe,

34:36.065 --> 34:37.485
our own nation, our own race.

34:37.715 --> 34:39.885
That has to be, it shouldn't matter.

34:40.025 --> 34:42.485
You should be able to give to anyone,

34:42.625 --> 34:45.285
in the us How do we, you know, is that something

34:45.285 --> 34:47.765
that would resonate with contemporary evangelicals who are

34:47.765 --> 34:50.605
so concerned about the border,

34:50.735 --> 34:52.485
about preserving a white America,

34:52.785 --> 34:57.445
and here's one of their forebearers, WWJD, you know,

34:57.445 --> 34:59.325
people wear this on their wristbands,

34:59.345 --> 35:00.925
was promoting Christian socialism.

35:00.955 --> 35:03.965
Like, is there something there that could be reclaimed

35:03.965 --> 35:06.365
by religious traditions that seemed to really be moving

35:07.345 --> 35:08.685
in a different direction?

35:08.905 --> 35:11.765
Um, you know, are there some folks out there that want

35:11.785 --> 35:15.245
to recapture Klaus's vision that sort of the gospel

35:15.345 --> 35:18.285
of charity trumps the gospel of wealth, Carnegie's vision.

35:19.105 --> 35:21.485
So, that's kind of what I hope, you know,

35:21.485 --> 35:23.965
when people read the book, they might come with those kinds

35:23.965 --> 35:26.645
of questions and really be self-reflective

35:26.665 --> 35:29.285
and see if there are things to learn, sort

35:29.285 --> 35:30.405
of cautionary tales

35:30.835 --> 35:33.085
that we can take away from the Christian Herald,

35:33.085 --> 35:37.325
but also, maybe some truths that would help reshape,

35:37.395 --> 35:39.325
some of the ways that debates about poverty

35:39.545 --> 35:43.045
and disaster are carried out in, in the moment today.

00:00 - As a scholar, I've been interested in exploring how Christians define and deal with various kinds of suffering. So my first book was called Faith in the Great Physicians, suffering in Divine Healing in American Protestantism from 1816 to 1900.

00:15 - And in that I explored how a group of Christians in the late 19th century US coped with physical illness, during a time of really great theological change and also innovation in the medical sciences. So when I got done with that book and I thought, okay, I've, I've thought about how it is that Christians deal with physical suffering within themselves, but what about suffering out in the world? What about when they encountered the suffering of others?

00:42 - How did they respond to various forms of suffering, like humanitarian disasters, famines, floods, earthquakes, suffering caused by war or imperialism or economic downturns? and how did Christians in the late 19th century decide which kinds of those sufferings they would pay attention to, who suffering mattered, and how to respond to it? So those were some of the things that got me interested in researching this book that eventually led to Holy Humanitarians.

01:13 - Yeah, so I first started researching this questions of, Christians confronting various forms of suffering through missionary archives. So I was deep in the bells of Yale Divinity School archives and some missionary records, and I came across this reference to the Christian Herald Association, which was sponsoring an orphanage in Fuji China. so I was thinking about suffering of children who were left parentless

01:40 - and thinking about missionaries on the field. And I thought, well, what is that thing the Christian Herald? Something I hadn't heard about? So, I started digging around and eventually I discovered that the Christian Herald was the world's most popular Christian newspaper from about 1890 to 1910. And that played a really major role in publicizing and responding to suffering across the United States

02:04 - and around the globe during its heyday, while also supporting various charitable organizations like the orphanage in eo, a Fresh Air Summer Home for children in the state of New York, an industrial school and post reconstruction air, the post reconstruction Air South, and most prominently, the Bowery Mission, which is a soup kitchen in New York City that still exists today. So, so I, this was what the newspaper was.

02:31 - So I started to look for copies of it, and I eventually discovered that the only surviving full run of the newspaper was housed in the Christian Harald Harald headquarters in New York City, which still existed. The newspaper was no longer being published at that time, but the Bowery Mission was still in operation. So I wrote to the, director of Outreach, James Macklin, and he invited me to come down and take a look. And, over the next several years, I spent hours and hours in the back room

03:03 - of the Christian Herald headquarters, getting to know James Macklin, the current president of the Bar mission today, James Winans, his colleague Julie Roma, and, ed Morgan, who was the president of that time at the, at the mission. And they really, I'm saying all this because it wasn't a traditional archival experience they had, I had to really gain their trust and they had to trust me to tell their story.

03:29 - and they became really important conversation partners over the course of that time. I'm really grateful to them for allowing access to that treasured resource. And I think one of the things I'm most proud of about the project is the fact that, with the partnership of the Tufts Library, which I'm also very grateful for, we were able to digitize through internet archive, a full, most of the run of the newspaper.

03:56 - So now it exists for other scholars to be able to look at. So now if you go to internet archive and you see the Christian Herald, you can do your own research and there's, you know, so much, it's a fantastic research for thinking about religion in general. Humanitarianism in particular, during, from the 1880s, we have digitized up to about 1920, and we're still have a little piece left to go. So, besides that, you know, I spent a lot

04:22 - of time in archives, other archives of other missionary newspapers, looking at correspondence of the main figures, thinking about looking at competing organizations, which I may talk about at, at some point. The Red Cross was at the major competitor for the Christian Herald at the time. so that's what I did. Yeah, so as I said, the Christian Herald really was the most influential

04:45 - religious newspaper in the US during its heyday from 1890 to about 1910. And really key to that CE success was Louis Klos, who was an entrepreneurial philanthropist who purchased the paper in 1890 and really worked to make it the nation's premier purveyor of humanitarian aid. And he partnered with this really charismatic preacher named Thomas dewitt Talmage, who is the pastor of the Brooklyn Tabernacle Church,

05:15 - which was at the time the United States largest congregation. So the two of them, really teamed up to combine biblical teachings about charity with emerging technologies of modern journalism. So things that we think of, sometimes we think about yellow journalism, it's right in that era. So they use gripping headlines, heartrending reporting, graphic photographs of suffering people to convince readers

05:44 - that aiding the affliction. The afflicted was really the obligation of every American citizen. So what they did was they solicited firsthand accounts of suffering and also photographs of calamities from this vast network of missionaries that they knew throughout the United States and around the world. So again, that connection to China is because they had a personal connection

06:08 - with those missionaries, and they, they were also, although Talmage himself was a member of the Christian reform denomination, they were very nondenominational. So the newspaper reached out was Presbyterians Episcopalians, Methodist Baptist, Dutch Reformed, I mean, any, they really had this idea of being broadly evangelical, and they used a small e it wasn't, we don't, we wanna be careful not to conflate the meaning of

06:37 - that term, and I'll get into a little bit more about what they meant by it at the time. So they just had these contexts, in all different denominations. And then they capitalized on sort of the interdenominational context and technological innovations. I've talked a little bit about journalism, but for example, this is also the era of the invention of the transatlantic telegraph.

06:59 - So that may possible the rapid transmission of news. So they could get a report about political conflict in Armenia from the missionaries over there right away, you know, as opposed to waiting for letters to come by boat. similarly, the introduction of the Kodak portable camera in 1888 enabled eyewitnesses to document humanitarian catastrophes going on. And then there were printing processes that facilitated the reproduction of those images in the paper,

07:28 - and they were really at the cutting edge of that journalism. We don't hear about them often when we think about some of the other magnates in journalism at the time, but they really did, pioneer a lot of those efforts. And so what they hoped was so combining these firsthand accounts of disasters happening around the world, these vivid photography would both raise awareness of affliction and also sell newspapers, which it did. It was very successful at both things.

07:57 - So I think one of the things to keep in mind is that, you know, CoLab and Talmage are, really complicated individuals with who were very successful and, and clear about their ambitions for their newspaper. and they combined sort of their religious faith with this, you know, very entrepreneurial spirit. so they started out, like at first kind of chronicling their, these different catastrophes. So there was a big famine in Russia in 1892. and then they very quickly turned from just saying like,

08:29 - Hey, there's all these things going on to making a case that their readers had a moral obligation to respond. And then actually using the newspaper as a fundraising tool, to collect money that then they would send abroad to, provide relief. So that's kind of a, a little sketch of how the newspaper got started, and I can, I'm happy to talk about, kind of continue the story of how they expanded Outward to different humanitarian com campaigns.

08:57 - Yeah, so I mean, as you say, there's a really broad array of, examples we could talk about. So the Bowery mission, the homelessness among New York City's unemployed, became the most enduring of their ministries. I mentioned before the industrial school in the south, in South Carolina that, catered to formerly enslaved persons get providing education. And then they had, you know, beginning in Russia moving

09:23 - through Armenia to, Cuba, India, China, Scandinavia, Macedonia, Japan, Italy, Mexico, San Francisco. They had all kinds of humanitarian campaigns. So a disaster would happen. They would publicize it, they would say, we're opening the Christian Herald Famine Relief campaign, send your donations in. And then every week they would publish a list of people who had donated to the cause.

09:51 - And at a certain point they would close the, close the fund, and then they would send all the money to missionaries. So just for example, during the India famine campaign of 1900, which was their most successful campaign, and which also I may, if I can at one point hold up the cover of the book, it's the image of the cover of the book, is sort of celebrating this successful famine relief campaign. They collected over $1.2 million for food assistance, medicine and orphan care.

10:20 - and all of those offerings, like I said, went directly to local volunteers, and those were usually missionaries. And India, it certainly was, they created a missionary council that included representatives from different denominations in India, and those volunteers doled out the money, right? They decided where it most needed to go. So the strategy was the missionaries, we've got this network of people already on the ground. They know the language, they know the culture,

10:48 - they're familiar with the needs and conditions, and therefore they can disseminate aid quickly and effectively. So in this way, to the Christian Herald really set itself apart deliberately from, emerging competitors like the American Red Cross. So in Armenia, there was a, at, at the Ottoman Empire, at a certain point was targeting Armenian Christians, and there was a massacres happening, and American missionaries had been there for almost a century, really decades at that point.

11:19 - So the Christian Herald sort of was in contact printing letters from missionaries explaining what was happening, sending relief to the missionaries to provide for people on the ground. The American Red Cross sent over American aid workers, Clara Barton herself went, and it was really challenging because she didn't know the language, she had no idea what the politics were. And so the Christian Herald was sort of setting itself up saying, Hey, you know,

11:46 - we've got a network and this is how age should be done. At the same time, early on, Claire Barton was a notoriously poor record keeper, and the Christian Herald made a point of publishing an audited account of its like, here's all the money we received, here's how we were spent it. And they publish a balance sheet, you know, after the close of the campaign and really tried to say, you know, we are,

12:10 - we should be entrusted with, I mean, at this time, it's important to remember there is no infrastructure at the federal level for providing aid. There's no U-S-A-I-D, there's no agencies that are officially doing this. So the Christian Herald is trying to say, we should be at the forefront of this for the American Nation. And they were arguing as well that having an explicitly religious vision for aid was something important

12:39 - that would identify the United States as a different kind of world power than other world powers. So they sort of had this idea that we're not going to be imperialists like the British, right. We're not gonna establish an empire. We're gonna establish a moral empire, and that's gonna be pervade through Christian charity. So they're really quite successful. By the time Lops died in 1910, subscribers have donated over $3.3 million

13:10 - to both domestic and international crises. And that's about in today's good dollars. So 2024, it's about a hundred million dollars in aid. And really the Red Cross by, at that exact moment, no other relief organization came remotely close to that fundraising capacity or sort of popular concern for suffering. So, I can talk a little bit more about why I think, do I have a couple more minutes to say why I think they were so successful?

13:41 - Yeah. Well, I mean, definitely, I mean, and Lops had lots of critics. There's a, I mean, part of the book that I love is just the absolute, like take down fight between himself and Clara Barton, who, I mean, she, he thought she was, you know, egotistical and, you know, not a poor poorly managing her organization. And she thought he was, a real charlatan, right?

14:04 - That he was. And so they really, really disagreed with one another. And, but he was a very savvy businessman. so, but he also had a message, I mean, think Klos and Talmage had this message, and it was multi-pronged. So one part of it was that philanthropy is something that every American should be involved in, right? This wasn't an elite practice. And at some point, I'll talk about sort of the contrast between the Christian Herald

14:31 - and say the rise of, the big Carnegie Rockefeller sort of wealthy family. So that model of philanthropy, coop and Alman said, you know what? Every person, even if you have a nickel or a dime, that's gonna make a difference, that can buy a loaf of bread. And they actually would publicize, like Sunday school classes would send in, would like take collections,

14:53 - and kids would go without dinner for a week and send the money that they're gonna spend on dinner to the Christian Herald. And so this was this sort of popular democratizing thing that he said, and they said, should be characteristic of Americans, like, this is how Americans were gonna stand out in the world. and they also, like, the part of the religious dimension is I mentioned before that they are trying

15:18 - to build bridges across various denominations. So the 1880s and nineties is when we're just starting to see in the United States debates among American Protestants about how to interpret the Bible. we are seeing social prejudices with the, fall of reconstruction in the South, and sort of an attempt to overcome the divisiveness of the Civil War. disagreements about race. We're seeing debates about immigration to the United States,

15:48 - particularly from Asia, but also Russia, Eastern Europe. so there's a lot of antagonism and cultural conflicts in the American public, and they are arguing that we can get past debates about all of these things, especially theology, if we just focus on what Americans have in common and what Americans have in common. And by Americans at that time, they made American Protestants mostly.

16:16 - We can not worry about, you know, that one of the, my bet the best lines that to, in the book is like, who cares? Who wrote the penit took the first five books of the Bible? Like, let's not worry about that, but let's worry about that. We're following Jesus' command to love your neighbor as yourself. Like certainly that's the golden rule. We can all agree on it.

16:34 - So that was sort of one thing that they did. and in order to do that, they're like, we're not gonna talk about all these controversial subjects in the newspaper, so we're not gonna publicize if you know so and so in the Presbyterian denomination is kicked out for being a heretic for how he interprets the Bible. and also, we're not gonna publicize, you know, we're not gonna be political, we're not, they did talk about they would, have coverage of presidential candidates and that sort of thing,

17:03 - but they would do both sides. and although their most, their target audience is white Protestants, they also were somewhat ecumenical. they took pains to include stories about African American churches and charities. they reported on the plight of Native Americans at the time, which is pretty unique for American Protestants.

17:26 - they also were very pro-immigration and anti the Chinese Exclusion Act or the Asian Exclusion Act that were, so, they were very welcoming towards Asian immigrants. they highlight the work of Jewish philanthropists, and they actually built some bridges with Catholics and all of that at a time when lots of Protestant leaders were supporting racial segregation, expressing antisemitism and accusing the pope of trying

17:53 - to take over the United States with these, you know, conspiracy theories. Like this was somewhat noteworthy that they did have this very big tent kind of attitude. and then another sort of theology point, and this can be my last one if I'm running outta time on this question, was that, by sort of publicizing all of these events all around the world, they, so they had on one hand, like g that our, we love our neighbors ourselves.

18:19 - That's a key text. Another key text is, acts 17 from the New Testament, God has made one blood of one blood all nations of men or of human beings, we would say now. And that was, you know, charity had to be worldwide. It didn't matter about race, class or nationality. So they also regularly quoted, story of the Good Samaritan who crossed racial and ethnic lines and saying, we can't just be concerned, we can't be tribal. We can't just be concerned about our own denomination

18:51 - or our own region, but we have to extend mercy and charity around the world. So, and this is where maybe, I don't know if we'll be able to see this too. Well, there's, I have to un blur my background for a second. Yeah, there it is. So the cover of the Christian Herald is from, this is a photograph from their 1900 newspaper cover that shows the success of the India Famine campaign.

19:17 - And you can see how they're, representing here a lot of their different efforts. So there's a veiled woman here, probably from the Armenian campaign. There's the Indian Famine Relief here. this is the Bowery mission represented here, and all of this here again, this is the children's home being represented. So, and it's titled America The Almanar of the World. And this is a really, I mean,

19:43 - I can say more about this later as well, it's a really complicated image, but it shows that they felt that the United States was this redeemer nation that possessed this unique power and resources to help the need and oppressed. So it's a very, when I show it to my students, they're like, that's the, you know, genesis of the white savior image. I'm like, yes, it is. In some ways I don't wanna claim that that's the start,

20:07 - but that's very much like, let's go out into the world not through an imperial frame or if the imperial frame is going to be through charity. that gets a little complicated when they get involved. And the America does become an imperial power, when it, gets involved in the Philippine war. And there they start to argue, you see a pivot where like, well, actually, you know, if war is being done to liberate oppressed peoples elsewhere, it can be a form of humanitarianism too.

20:37 - and that's one place where we start to get into tensions where critics start to say, wait a second. Like, is that really, like, who, who who is saying who needs to be liberated? is this kind of hierarchical image really representing the kingdom of God? That that is saying all nations of men are, you know, in Jesus Christ, every, there's neither Jew nor Greek slave, nor free male nor female. So now I'm speaking from the voice of many

21:04 - of the missionaries on the ground who felt that some of the Christian Herald's perspective was somewhat paternalistic, right. And imperialistic in its own way. Yeah. So there's a couple different factors that go into the decline. I mean, one is, as I just, the solidarity that they built becomes increasingly difficult to maintain, right? Especially after cops dies in 1910.

21:26 - So as, tensions mount within Protestantism around biblical interpretations, we've got the beginnings of debates between what come, come to be called fundamentalist Christians and modernist Christians. It's hard for the Christian Herald to ignore that, right? And then over time, eventually those groups, both fundamentalists and modernists begin to create their own newspapers. So, the modernists create the Christian century.

21:54 - Eventually by the 1940s, the evangelicals, the fundamentalists who become then new evangelicals, so different worth use of the term than the way K and Talmage were using it, create Christianity today. and so market share goes down, right? That's one, issue. But even prior to that, there are a series of things. So the American red, so there's fractures with American presentism that I just described. there's the growth of the US state.

22:23 - So the, the federal government does begin to create at, in partnership with the Red Cross Act, actually a federal structure for overseas disaster relief. And that starts to happen at the turn of the century and into, and by World War I, the Red Cross is really a quasi-governmental agency. and in part it wins out because it does have a much more secular message, right? There's, it's not sort of wetting its message with this very explicitly biblical, campaign.

22:54 - By the 1930s, we have the expansion of the welfare state. So there's, you know, that in the US there's infrastructure being put in place to care for people who are falling through. There is a safety net where there wasn't in the 1880s and nineties. We also have the professionalization of social work. So social work, and, you know, philanthropy becomes its own aid. They're the creation of, you know, professional schools.

23:19 - You can become trained as a social worker. And that wasn't the case in the eighties and nineties. and then finally you've got the rise of these massive family foundations, the Carnegies and the Rockefellers, right? Really eclipse and diminish the Christian Herald stature as a relief agency. So, and that's a point it might be worth

23:39 - dwelling on a little bit. I've talked about sort of this sense that, Talmage and CLOs had that you have to aid anyone who needs help, right? And they did both. I mean, they were really about emergency relief. and at the same time they did lobby for broader structural solutions as well, but they start to get really critiqued. So one of the signature, the surviving entity

24:05 - of the Christian Herald today is really the Bowery mission in New York City. that, enterprise, as long as, as well as other sort of soup kitchens in New York, came under blistering attack in the early 20th century by proponents of what was called scientific charity. So one of the leaders of that movement was the industrial magnate, Andrew Carnegie, right? And Carnegie, in his view, if wealth came to the worthy, like if you worked hard,

24:35 - if you saved responsibly, if you lived a virtuous life, you would become wealthy. Therefore, if you were poor, that meant that you were lazy, irresponsible and engaging in some kind of immoral, maybe usually drunken behavior. I mean, maybe there were some times where, you know, there was some kind of misfortune, but by, and by, like, that was the equation. So the job of philanthropists was to work scientifically.

25:05 - That was the term, to figure out who deserved help. Like the deserving poor, maybe those who were trying to pull themselves up by their bootstraps, or maybe they had a misfortune, and the derelicts who lived off free handouts, right? And so we still have this in our culture, right? There's still debates about who really deserves help. So Carnegie and his, allies in the San Scientific Charity movement said, if you're gonna run a soup kitchen like the Barry Mission,

25:32 - you're just perpetuating the problem. Like you are, enabling people to live off the doll. And instead you should, sort of go out and register people, and you figure out not give aid to anybody who doesn't really work for it and deserve it. And you should establish institutions to help people sort of work their way up. So libraries, we've got the Carnegie Library in New York, right?

25:57 - We've got, educational institutions, art galleries, public parks. So it was sort of, you give people the tools to learn how to help themselves. So as this kind of idea gains authority, ction Talmage are basically acknowledge like, okay, there are some scientific methods that maybe could help us improve efficiency in philanthropy, but they really repudiated the claim that charity led to delinquency.

26:24 - And I think this has to do in part with, sort of being, again, like closer to the ground, and involved in this charitable work. So rather than blaming the needy or unemployed for their situation, K and Talmage both, like, especially in around the eight later 1890s turn of the 20th century, really tried to publish articles saying, we've gotta get to the root of the problem. And what would we call today?

26:51 - They didn't use this language, but we would say they started to recognize the structural elements of inequality, right? And to, and they did say, I mean, they were always, they would never say this directly about Carnegie. They did feature him, you know, in their newspaper as a, you know, philanthropist. But they did say things like, if, if anybody was to be accounta held accountable for suffering,

27:16 - it was the wealthy industrialists who weren't paying a fair wage, who were inflating prices, who were amassing colossal fortunes on the backs of their workers, extracting resources from colonized peoples. So they said, you know, in, again, in somewhat of a diplomatic way, most of the time, that instead of building libraries, I mean, well, colleges, libraries, all that's great, but what really need to happen is that Carnegie should offer higher salaries, explain,

27:47 - expand employment opportunities, support legislation to ensure fair labor and housing conditions. and one of their, in the 19 early 20th century, actually, so the early 19 hundreds, one of their, featured authors was a minister named Charles Sheldon. Charles Sheldon is famous today for the acronym what ww JD what would Jesus do? and he published a serial novel in the pages that Christian Herald, called Christian Socialism. And he basically argued for what a sort of a program of,

28:25 - pri of making, you know, private, like common goods, common ownership of public utilities, that sort of thing, redistributing wealth, like it really was a, a socialistic vision of the future. And that's partly what Talmage were behind as well. So a really different, but, but in the end, like that, just that vision as we know in the United States, does not win out. it is the vision of the Carnegies and the Rockefellers, and eventually they, they just can't compete with

28:56 - the massive fortunes that are put together and the family foundations that are set up to preserve that generational wealth. And they, they just can't compete in the marketplace either of sort of religious newspapers or of philanthropic foundations. And so they, they sort of pull back, they start focusing the paper. I mean, KLO dies, Talmage died earlier. So by like the time of World War One,

29:22 - the new editors of the paper decide they're gonna refocus the paper on more religious themes, and they're gonna kind of divest themselves of most of its charitable enterprise, with the exception of the Bowery Mission. And the, it's called, it was called Mont Lawn Children's Camp. And it exists today still in some children's programs that the Barry Mission runs. they kept on publishing the paper until about the 1990s,

29:47 - and then they closed it down. And now the, it really, if you go online looking for the Christian Herald Association, you'll find the Barry Mission and, they're still going strong. Yeah. So I think there's, the book has a lot to teach us about the topics of humanitarianism, and I talk about this, mostly in the epilogue. So I mean, I'll I'll say kind of in two, two things. One is, although, you know, nobody's heard

30:13 - of the Christian Herald today, right? I mean, unless you've read my book, maybe unless you've been to the Bar Mission, everybody's heard of the Rockefeller Foundation, Carnegie the American Red Cross, and yet I really do believe that the Christian Herald's relief campaigns left a lasting mark. I think, the cover that I showed before with the United States as this kind of savior alman

30:36 - or of all nations affected the way humanitarian relief happened even for the Red Cross. So in the book, I have an image of the Red Cross in, in World War i's very similar sort of presenting the United States, having this divinely ordained responsibility to rescue the afflicted and the United States throughout the 20th century, really engaged in a lot of humanitarian interventions, you know, often staged as war, right? As well, just like it was in the Philippines.

31:05 - And, you know, if we were to catalog a lot, those, like many of those relief efforts have saved lives. there's also been critics of those aid agents, agencies, and efforts. So my own colleague at Tufts, Alex Deval and others have talked about how disaster remediation and development activities have often fueled corruption and host countries exacerbated poverty, bolstered authoritarian regimes. So there's that, to think about.

31:35 - There's also the use of images. I mean, the Christian Herald really was, I do make a case that they're really the pioneer of using what gets called, you know, famine porn, really just these images of people in pain and aid agencies have relied on those kind kinds of images up to the present. I mean, I think, we can think about, you know, recent IMA images in the US of, border crossers, people coming from Mexico into the US

32:03 - and their shock value, right? And so there too, I think ethicists really warn about the implications of that, those kind of images. They're effective, but they reinforce inequalities between privileged donors and relief recipients and sort of reproduce the structural, nature of that that requires us to have charity in the first place. So there's that to think about we with thinking about the Christian Herald, what can we learn from the blind spots, right,

32:32 - that the Christian Herald had? And what are the blind spots that we still have? So I think I chose that image for the cover because it's easy to judge that era, right? And say, look at how, you know, paternalistic they were. But we also can see that, you know, the ongoing legacy of that, I think in our own relief efforts today. On the other hand, I think the newspaper's arguments for extending compassion beyond national borders and social barriers remain really relevant.

33:03 - So I've already alluded to debates we have today in the US and really around the world about poverty assistance, immigration, global inequality, how do we create a justice society? so some of the questions I talked about with my friends that I made at the Christian Herald is, does charity create dependency? who gets to help from philanthropist, which disaster makes the news? We have this right now. I mean,

33:30 - what's happening in in Ethiopia, right? And, versus, and things that are getting coverage, things that don't, is what do we do about i meeting emergency needs versus trying to invest in efforts to alleviate structural inequality? how should a, an organization like the Barry mission today, like should they be trying to do both or should they concentrate on one?

33:54 - how can we encourage empathy for people who are suffering without reinforcing these inequalities, social disparities, racial discrimination, gender bias, nationalist hierarchies? So I think my hope is that in reading this book, people who are in trying to make the world a better place will recognize some of the things that get, that, you know, that can get involved when you start asking those questions. and maybe there's something in what, what the collapse and Talmage were saying that we might, learn from.

34:28 - So I, I wonder if clap to claim that true Christianity must, he said is can't be limited to our own tribe, our own nation, our own race. That has to be, it shouldn't matter. You should be able to give to anyone, in the us How do we, you know, is that something that would resonate with contemporary evangelicals who are so concerned about the border, about preserving a white America, and here's one of their forebearers, WWJD, you know,

34:57 - people wear this on their wristbands, was promoting Christian socialism. Like, is there something there that could be reclaimed by religious traditions that seemed to really be moving in a different direction? you know, are there some folks out there that want to recapture Klaus's vision that sort of the gospel of charity trumps the gospel of wealth, Carnegie's vision. So, that's kind of what I hope, you know, when people read the book, they might come with those kinds

35:23 - of questions and really be self-reflective and see if there are things to learn, sort of cautionary tales that we can take away from the Christian Herald, but also, maybe some truths that would help reshape, some of the ways that debates about poverty and disaster are carried out in, in the moment today.

Faculti AI can make mistakes