Popular in Professional

Culture and Society

The City as a Growth Machine: Toward a Political Economy of Place

New York University Harvey Moltoch

Education

The Role of Education in Reducing Racial Inequality

University of Southern California Pedro A. Noguera

Law

Diversity and Social Mobility in the UK legal profession

Law Society I. Stephanie Boyce

Internet Law

The Law of AI for Good

University of San Diego Orly Lobel

Pharmacy

Cytotoxic Activity and Anti-Migratory Effect of Berberine-Phytantriol Liquid Crystalline on Non-Small-Cell Lung Cancer

University of Technology Sydney Kamal Dua

Human Rights Law

Transforming Restorative Justice for Transitional Settings

University of Nottingham Kerry Clamp

Education

Middle-class mothers’ participation in tutoring for spoken English

View more insights in Professional - Education - Sociology of Education

View more figures from University of Southampton

View the page of Achala Gupta

Read the Study

Sociological inquiries on parental involvement seldom consider the investments parents make in themselves to realise educational advantages in their children’s schooling. This gap hides the processes underlying class-making and class-produced privileges. Achala Gupta investigates middle-class mothers’ participation in tutoring and coaching for spoken English in Dehradun, India, focusing on their reasons for soliciting such paid tutoring support.

Image courtesy of interviewee. May 23, 2024

Generating Workspace

Export as PDF

This video video discusses the growing significance and complexities of the middle class, particularly in the context of consumer behavior and education. It highlights that the middle class is the fastest-growing consumer group globally, with 3.2 billion people contributing to annual consumption of approximately $40 trillion. Notably, 88% of the next billion people joining this social class will come from Asia.

The narrative spans across different sociocultural contexts, emphasizing how middle-class parents employ various forms of capital to maintain their social status and enhance their children's educational experiences. The study underlines that in India, the middle class is a contested category with diverse interpretations shaped by historical and economic contexts.

Key findings from the research highlight that Indian middle-class mothers seek English tutoring for three main reasons: to improve their teaching capabilities at home, to reinforce English as a communicative language, and to facilitate better collaboration with school teachers. This video video pursuit is seen as a means to assert their middle-class identity and privilege, despite feeling that they do not fully belong to this group.

The discussion also delves into the intra-class dynamics between traditional and new middle-class families, underlining disparities in educational backgrounds and cultural capital. In conclusion, the study suggests a broader need to investigate parental investments in children's education from a more nuanced perspective, focusing on the efforts of parents themselves, particularly mothers, as they navigate educational landscapes to secure a better future for their children.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.185 --> 00:03.165
As we know, middle class is the world's fastest

00:03.235 --> 00:04.525
growing consumer group.

00:04.945 --> 00:06.005
Um, lots

00:06.005 --> 00:08.605
of research has been done on this particular group from

00:08.605 --> 00:11.285
different perspectives, economy, society,

00:11.385 --> 00:12.485
policy, et cetera.

00:12.825 --> 00:16.965
Um, we know from these research that middle class

00:17.025 --> 00:18.725
as a consumer group contributes

00:18.825 --> 00:20.725
to the total annual consumption

00:20.865 --> 00:23.685
of approximately $40 trillion.

00:24.305 --> 00:27.685
Uh, approximately 3.2 billion people belong

00:27.685 --> 00:30.925
to this social category with expected early edition

00:30.925 --> 00:33.085
of 140 million.

00:33.745 --> 00:38.685
Uh, so the main point to consider here is that Asia

00:39.755 --> 00:44.245
will contribute about 88% of the next billion added

00:44.505 --> 00:47.565
to social class, as a global category.

00:47.985 --> 00:50.845
So obviously middle class is a privileged group,

00:51.185 --> 00:53.845
but much more importantly, it is a diverse group.

00:53.915 --> 00:58.245
Different concepts of what it means to belong to this group,

00:58.905 --> 01:02.485
across societies are talked about in a

01:02.485 --> 01:03.845
variety of a scholarship.

01:04.465 --> 01:09.285
So, so that was the first point of, context.

01:09.715 --> 01:13.165
Another context here is the sociology of education.

01:13.465 --> 01:16.005
So in the field of sociology of education, we know

01:16.005 --> 01:19.285
that middle class parents use a variety of capital

01:19.545 --> 01:21.605
to a gain social privilege.

01:22.205 --> 01:25.965
B, reproduce their advantage, intergenerationally,

01:26.905 --> 01:30.955
therefore maintaining their class status in society.

01:31.495 --> 01:34.155
Uh, this was extensively talked about by Boer

01:34.415 --> 01:36.875
and many other scholars who draw on bo j's work.

01:37.375 --> 01:41.875
Uh, most notable is Annette Lara's work Unequal Childhoods,

01:42.175 --> 01:43.435
where she talks about

01:43.495 --> 01:46.475
how middle class families in the United States use various

01:46.875 --> 01:49.355
resources to concertedly cultivate

01:49.965 --> 01:51.995
their children's educational experiences.

01:52.815 --> 01:56.185
Um, when it comes to India,

01:56.185 --> 01:59.305
because obviously this is the broader conceptual,

02:00.985 --> 02:03.315
broader conceptual framework of the study,

02:03.455 --> 02:06.395
but more empirically speaking in India,

02:06.415 --> 02:10.035
middle class is a heavily contested category,

02:10.035 --> 02:12.635
and it can be explained both relationally

02:13.535 --> 02:17.075
and tentatively rather than in an absolute term

02:17.255 --> 02:21.835
and in a more defined ways, which means people

02:21.895 --> 02:24.675
who identify as middle class tend

02:24.675 --> 02:27.035
to have a substantially different experience

02:27.035 --> 02:28.475
of being middle class.

02:29.175 --> 02:33.155
Uh, so two broad categories are traditional middle classes,

02:33.455 --> 02:37.315
which are often privileged economically, educationally,

02:37.375 --> 02:41.075
and socio culturally intergenerationally in colonial

02:41.135 --> 02:43.835
and post-colonial times, new middle classes.

02:44.335 --> 02:46.755
Um, often this,

02:47.455 --> 02:51.795
new middle classes really represent, this new group

02:51.895 --> 02:55.875
of professionals who were not as economically, socially,

02:55.875 --> 02:58.435
and culturally resourceful intergenerationally,

02:58.855 --> 03:03.365
but actually emerged as a aftermath most recently due

03:03.365 --> 03:07.685
to the, opening up of the economy in India in the 1990s.

03:08.065 --> 03:09.645
So the it boom, et cetera.

03:10.505 --> 03:13.985
So Indian middle class,

03:14.965 --> 03:17.265
if you go through the literature, you would find,

03:17.765 --> 03:21.065
invest heavily in their children's education.

03:21.525 --> 03:23.945
Uh, in my own work previously I have talked about

03:24.125 --> 03:26.745
how Indian Middle class consider investment in their

03:26.865 --> 03:30.705
children's education a necessary to compensate

03:30.765 --> 03:32.145
for their perceived inability

03:32.165 --> 03:34.225
to help their children academically themselves.

03:34.845 --> 03:38.385
Second, they consider it, or it,

03:38.995 --> 03:41.415
or it could be conceptualized rather as a case

03:41.515 --> 03:43.735
of exchanging economic resources

03:44.275 --> 03:45.695
for desired cultural capital.

03:46.555 --> 03:50.535
Um, and it consolidates their home-based really resources

03:50.835 --> 03:54.175
to gain their class situated social advantage.

03:54.315 --> 03:57.215
And I think this is the broader context in which this

03:57.215 --> 03:58.815
particular study is situated.

03:59.435 --> 04:03.175
Um, and if I could just tease out

04:03.365 --> 04:07.855
what it means is, so far what we know is

04:07.855 --> 04:10.335
that such studies offer, you know,

04:10.935 --> 04:13.215
valuable insights into various critical

04:13.515 --> 04:16.575
and various critical social and educational processes.

04:17.575 --> 04:20.855
Seldom, there is a consideration of experiences

04:21.115 --> 04:24.575
of parents themselves, about sort

04:24.575 --> 04:27.015
of holding their own skills in order to help their children.

04:27.085 --> 04:28.935
It's all about what they do for their children.

04:29.915 --> 04:34.095
But what I'm trying to do in this paper is what do they do

04:34.355 --> 04:37.295
for themselves in order to aid and help their children?

04:37.595 --> 04:40.255
So slightly different take in terms of

04:40.365 --> 04:43.215
what we know about parental involvement in their child,

04:43.305 --> 04:46.535
their engagement with their children's education field work

04:46.535 --> 04:49.895
for which was conducted in the, in India,

04:50.075 --> 04:51.335
the foothills of Elias.

04:51.875 --> 04:56.535
Um, I conducted two group interviews involving 12 mothers

04:56.675 --> 04:59.775
who solicited private tutoring for spoken English.

05:00.515 --> 05:03.255
And the group interviews were about two, two

05:03.255 --> 05:04.655
and a half hours long.

05:04.915 --> 05:07.055
Um, and they were held in tutorial centers

05:07.905 --> 05:11.335
after the participants scheduled spoken English sessions.

05:11.875 --> 05:13.415
So this was a deliberate attempt

05:13.415 --> 05:16.975
because they didn't wanna talk to me about their experiences

05:17.235 --> 05:21.385
of taking tuition as adults in their homes.

05:22.165 --> 05:24.785
And so I purposely chose that the site has

05:24.785 --> 05:27.225
to be somewhere they felt most comfortable.

05:27.405 --> 05:29.145
So therefore, it was a tutorial center.

05:30.025 --> 05:33.525
The, the key findings really were that mother's reason

05:34.225 --> 05:38.085
for subscribing to tutorial, services

05:38.345 --> 05:41.885
and coaching for spoken English tends to be threefold.

05:41.935 --> 05:44.565
First is, English proficiency

05:44.745 --> 05:46.965
for effective home teaching so

05:47.085 --> 05:50.485
that they can be a good teacher for their kids at home.

05:51.025 --> 05:53.245
Second is to reinforce English

05:53.345 --> 05:55.325
as a language of communication.

05:55.825 --> 05:58.845
And the third was that English tutoring,

05:59.065 --> 06:02.645
for effective partnership with school teachers.

06:03.625 --> 06:07.595
So as a synthesis of the main argument, if you will,

06:07.595 --> 06:10.235
would be that English private tutoring was really seen

06:10.235 --> 06:12.235
by these mothers as a way to unlock

06:12.845 --> 06:14.315
urban middle class identity

06:14.535 --> 06:17.075
and privilege, which they felt they did not

06:17.075 --> 06:18.355
quite belong to this group.

06:18.415 --> 06:20.635
And this was their way to say, Hey,

06:21.155 --> 06:22.195
actually I am middle class.

06:22.615 --> 06:26.315
So it's to gain social legitimacy of being a middle class,

06:26.775 --> 06:28.795
given that they did not quite

06:28.945 --> 06:30.235
feel that they were part of the group.

06:30.535 --> 06:33.635
So I will just go through each of these three reasons one

06:33.635 --> 06:35.435
by one just to expand on it.

06:35.815 --> 06:37.715
Uh, the first one was English proficiency

06:37.895 --> 06:39.475
for effective home teaching.

06:40.785 --> 06:44.245
So we know from the literature about the school choice,

06:44.395 --> 06:47.005
both of the middle class parents, especially

06:47.005 --> 06:49.125
because I spoke with, middle

06:49.225 --> 06:51.685
to upper middle class parents, they often

06:52.105 --> 06:54.605
or not often, they always made sure

06:54.605 --> 06:56.765
that they were enrolling their children to high fee

06:56.865 --> 07:01.085
as opposed to low fee private schools, where the medium

07:01.145 --> 07:03.005
of instruction was always English.

07:03.585 --> 07:07.925
Uh, teaching at home, was seen by these parents

07:08.025 --> 07:10.565
as the most valuable form of parenting.

07:11.945 --> 07:16.005
Um, and so English proficiency was one of the crucial skills

07:16.545 --> 07:18.805
for them to provide effective teaching

07:18.865 --> 07:21.525
and learning support to their children at home.

07:22.025 --> 07:26.245
So if I were to read just one extract from my study, one

07:26.245 --> 07:28.645
of the mothers, for example, said, when I spent time

07:28.645 --> 07:30.085
with my kids, I realize

07:30.085 --> 07:33.125
that English proficiency is necessary for us referring

07:33.125 --> 07:35.365
to other mothers to be just able

07:35.385 --> 07:39.485
to engage in their children's everyday subject best lessons,

07:39.945 --> 07:41.445
as well as everyday learning.

07:41.905 --> 07:43.445
It is like, I know the topic,

07:43.745 --> 07:45.765
but don't know how to say things in English.

07:46.405 --> 07:49.005
I know for example, what group ion is,

07:49.625 --> 07:53.205
but it does not easily translate into gravity for me.

07:53.945 --> 07:57.765
Uh, so ion is the, ate handy word for gravity.

07:58.265 --> 08:03.125
Uh, so this really illustrates how mothers felt

08:03.125 --> 08:05.845
that proficiency in English would allow them

08:06.715 --> 08:10.055
to become really effective teachers at home,

08:10.145 --> 08:12.455
which they thought was really very part of their parenting.

08:12.995 --> 08:17.015
The second reason was reinforcing English as a language

08:17.035 --> 08:18.055
of communication.

08:19.315 --> 08:22.735
So there's always this perceived language gap between

08:23.305 --> 08:24.855
themselves and their children.

08:24.925 --> 08:27.855
This was talked about by all the mothers,

08:29.235 --> 08:31.445
predominantly because they were all,

08:31.965 --> 08:33.805
learning subjects in English

08:33.985 --> 08:35.965
and mothers themselves even went to school.

08:36.355 --> 08:39.805
They all learned those subjects in Hindi or Ular language.

08:40.385 --> 08:42.445
Uh, for majority of them it was Hindi.

08:44.175 --> 08:46.235
So it prevented productive

08:46.975 --> 08:50.195
and constructive interaction interactions about

08:50.215 --> 08:51.315
school related matters.

08:51.415 --> 08:54.195
So if mothers wanted to know what the child was doing,

08:54.265 --> 08:55.705
they wouldn't fully grasp

08:55.705 --> 08:58.025
because the notes would be prepared in English.

08:58.405 --> 09:00.305
And when they would speak with their kids,

09:00.855 --> 09:02.705
kids might use some of the languages

09:02.705 --> 09:04.665
that they would not really be familiar with.

09:04.665 --> 09:07.785
So they always felt this language gap was actually becoming

09:07.945 --> 09:10.705
a gap between them knowing about what is going on in school.

09:11.445 --> 09:15.145
Uh, so this obviously had negative impact on substantial

09:15.435 --> 09:19.465
difference in linguistic environment at home

09:19.485 --> 09:21.945
and at school, meaning the environment,

09:21.945 --> 09:24.385
linguistic environment in school was English

09:24.525 --> 09:27.985
and linguistic environment in home tended to be Hindi

09:28.005 --> 09:31.065
or Ari language, which yeah, really languages.

09:31.645 --> 09:36.265
So an except from the interview is, so mother says,

09:36.495 --> 09:39.385
some teachers also think that if we continue talking

09:39.405 --> 09:42.265
to our kids in Hindi at home, they,

09:42.365 --> 09:46.305
the children are more likely to struggle to learn how

09:46.305 --> 09:49.025
to speak English fluently in the school environment.

09:49.765 --> 09:53.145
So if there is continuity in language at home

09:53.605 --> 09:56.825
and in school, children are more likely to progress

09:57.215 --> 09:58.745
with fewer difficulties.

09:59.125 --> 10:02.385
The purpose here was that was that mothers wanted

10:02.445 --> 10:04.665
to make their children's life a little bit easier

10:05.605 --> 10:09.925
and parents said this would be the remedy, so

10:09.925 --> 10:11.685
therefore they subscribe to private tutoring.

10:12.425 --> 10:15.005
The third reason was that English tutoring

10:15.065 --> 10:16.845
for effective partnership with school teachers.

10:16.845 --> 10:19.045
This sort of ex extends from the point

10:19.045 --> 10:20.805
that I raised just now.

10:21.305 --> 10:25.165
Um, so when we talk about school choice again in India,

10:25.185 --> 10:28.365
we see that educators' ability to communicate in English

10:28.505 --> 10:31.845
to train children in a culture of sharing

10:31.905 --> 10:33.805
and exchanging ideas in English.

10:34.345 --> 10:39.005
So this is why, the school choice of choosing a,

10:39.165 --> 10:41.885
a school that serves English as a medium of instruction.

10:42.385 --> 10:45.485
Um, however, this culture disparity

10:45.485 --> 10:47.045
between the school teachers and mothers,

10:47.045 --> 10:49.085
because mothers cannot communicate in that language,

10:49.725 --> 10:52.325
produced an interesting intra class dynamic.

10:53.105 --> 10:55.125
Now, why intra class dynamic is

10:55.125 --> 10:56.805
because whilst mothers claim

10:56.865 --> 11:00.125
to be middle class school teachers were also middle class.

11:00.585 --> 11:03.485
But the point here is that they both belong

11:03.485 --> 11:05.645
to different strands of middle class.

11:06.075 --> 11:09.485
They became middle class very differently, in other words.

11:09.945 --> 11:11.645
Uh, so the extract reads.

11:11.705 --> 11:14.485
Um, sometimes I also struggle

11:14.505 --> 11:16.965
to understand when teachers speak English fluently.

11:17.515 --> 11:20.085
Some teachers pronounce words differently from

11:20.085 --> 11:21.925
how many people I know would pronounce them

11:22.555 --> 11:24.725
even if they were communicating in English.

11:25.225 --> 11:28.325
So I just do not know what they're saying.

11:28.555 --> 11:30.325
This is incredibly challenging

11:30.325 --> 11:33.125
because I sometimes miss out on in important information.

11:33.225 --> 11:35.605
So this accent part is really important.

11:36.385 --> 11:39.965
Um, language ability for the traditional middle class

11:39.965 --> 11:43.725
to be able to communicate ideas fluently in English was very

11:43.725 --> 11:46.765
much inherent to their middle class identity, not so much

11:46.825 --> 11:50.125
for many groups in new middle class category.

11:50.225 --> 11:53.085
And so it shows the intra class dynamic

11:53.705 --> 11:57.605
and the disparity in how one becomes middle class.

11:58.435 --> 12:02.725
This paper basically signifies that tutoring could be used

12:03.025 --> 12:05.565
for unlocking a class identity.

12:05.945 --> 12:08.525
So in this case, mothers were using tutoring

12:08.665 --> 12:12.485
for unlocking urban middle class identity for themselves.

12:13.065 --> 12:16.205
Uh, it speaks to the contemporary understanding

12:16.225 --> 12:17.285
of middle class identity

12:17.385 --> 12:20.165
and privilege, broadly speaking outside of India,

12:20.165 --> 12:22.845
because just like in India,

12:23.505 --> 12:26.205
the way in which one becomes middle class is increasingly

12:26.485 --> 12:28.485
becoming much more diverse than used

12:28.485 --> 12:29.645
to be the case in the past.

12:30.305 --> 12:34.165
Uh, so therefore the new research agenda could be

12:34.165 --> 12:36.285
to really map those trajectories

12:36.465 --> 12:40.205
and see to what extent does it result into the kind

12:40.205 --> 12:42.805
of advantage in education and sports

12:42.945 --> 12:44.485
and health in other fields as well.

12:45.145 --> 12:48.885
Um, so that would be one way to approach it.

12:48.985 --> 12:50.845
The second is that what I try

12:50.845 --> 12:53.765
to touch on in this paper is under examine territory

12:53.865 --> 12:56.725
of parental investment in their children's education.

12:57.305 --> 13:01.165
So I try to move away from the discussions on parental

13:01.165 --> 13:04.005
investments from the lens of educational choices

13:05.225 --> 13:06.875
that parents make for their children

13:07.375 --> 13:09.515
to parental investment in themselves.

13:10.175 --> 13:13.595
Um, overall, the purpose of mothers to seek tutoring

13:13.695 --> 13:14.755
for spoken English was

13:14.755 --> 13:17.075
to ensure their children had sufficient resources

13:17.575 --> 13:19.435
to achieve their full academic potential.

13:19.435 --> 13:22.835
And so future research can examine what is going on at home

13:23.735 --> 13:27.235
rather than just looking at what is going on in

13:27.235 --> 13:29.555
between schools and home

13:30.255 --> 13:32.155
or just what is going on in the school.

13:32.855 --> 13:35.905
So that's the second contribution

13:36.085 --> 13:39.545
and sort of draws line for what could be done in the future

13:39.615 --> 13:41.065
with regards to research projects.

13:41.445 --> 13:44.825
The third point that I try to highlight in this paper is

13:45.045 --> 13:47.985
to signify middle class mothers' efforts

13:48.125 --> 13:50.145
to unlock their social class identity.

13:50.915 --> 13:55.225
Class identity is not always given,

13:55.445 --> 13:59.065
and that's what I try to sort of tease out, especially

13:59.065 --> 14:02.425
through that intra class dynamic between school teachers

14:02.725 --> 14:04.665
and parents both belong to middle class.

14:04.775 --> 14:06.745
They're very different kind of middle class.

14:07.245 --> 14:09.865
Uh, so many middle class mothers realize

14:09.895 --> 14:12.385
that they are economically middle class,

14:12.695 --> 14:14.305
they've got money still.

14:14.335 --> 14:17.705
They lack that critical cultural resources such

14:17.705 --> 14:22.695
as English proficiency, which traditionally,

14:23.075 --> 14:25.615
was associated with being middle class in India.

14:26.235 --> 14:29.815
So that shows how trajectory could be really important.

14:30.005 --> 14:33.575
Signifier to the, to inform whether

14:33.675 --> 14:37.375
or not you actually feel you belong to the group, you belong

14:37.375 --> 14:38.695
to a group is a different question.

14:39.075 --> 14:41.055
You feel you belong to a group is another.

14:41.675 --> 14:45.015
And so if future research could tease out those kind

14:45.015 --> 14:46.055
of differences and

14:46.075 --> 14:48.415
how those differences are experienced on the ground,

14:48.925 --> 14:50.775
that could be a interesting project

14:50.875 --> 14:53.245
In and of itself, particularly to elicit

14:54.105 --> 14:56.205
how then educational advantage

14:56.305 --> 14:59.685
and disadvantage, look like even

15:00.425 --> 15:02.845
in a very diversified format within

15:03.625 --> 15:05.085
one particular social class.

00:00 - As we know, middle class is the world's fastest growing consumer group. lots of research has been done on this particular group from different perspectives, economy, society, policy, et cetera.

00:12 - we know from these research that middle class as a consumer group contributes to the total annual consumption of approximately $40 trillion. approximately 3.2 billion people belong to this social category with expected early edition of 140 million. so the main point to consider here is that Asia will contribute about 88% of the next billion added to social class, as a global category.

00:47 - So obviously middle class is a privileged group, but much more importantly, it is a diverse group. Different concepts of what it means to belong to this group, across societies are talked about in a variety of a scholarship. So, so that was the first point of, context. Another context here is the sociology of education. So in the field of sociology of education, we know that middle class parents use a variety of capital to a gain social privilege.

01:22 - B, reproduce their advantage, intergenerationally, therefore maintaining their class status in society. this was extensively talked about by Boer and many other scholars who draw on bo j's work. most notable is Annette Lara's work Unequal Childhoods, where she talks about how middle class families in the United States use various resources to concertedly cultivate their children's educational experiences. when it comes to India,

01:56 - because obviously this is the broader conceptual, broader conceptual framework of the study, but more empirically speaking in India, middle class is a heavily contested category, and it can be explained both relationally and tentatively rather than in an absolute term and in a more defined ways, which means people who identify as middle class tend to have a substantially different experience of being middle class.

02:29 - so two broad categories are traditional middle classes, which are often privileged economically, educationally, and socio culturally intergenerationally in colonial and post-colonial times, new middle classes. often this, new middle classes really represent, this new group of professionals who were not as economically, socially, and culturally resourceful intergenerationally, but actually emerged as a aftermath most recently due to the, opening up of the economy in India in the 1990s.

03:08 - So the it boom, et cetera. So Indian middle class, if you go through the literature, you would find, invest heavily in their children's education. in my own work previously I have talked about how Indian Middle class consider investment in their children's education a necessary to compensate for their perceived inability to help their children academically themselves. Second, they consider it, or it,

03:38 - or it could be conceptualized rather as a case of exchanging economic resources for desired cultural capital. and it consolidates their home-based really resources to gain their class situated social advantage. And I think this is the broader context in which this particular study is situated. and if I could just tease out what it means is, so far what we know is that such studies offer, you know,

04:10 - valuable insights into various critical and various critical social and educational processes. Seldom, there is a consideration of experiences of parents themselves, about sort of holding their own skills in order to help their children. It's all about what they do for their children. But what I'm trying to do in this paper is what do they do for themselves in order to aid and help their children? So slightly different take in terms of what we know about parental involvement in their child,

04:43 - their engagement with their children's education field work for which was conducted in the, in India, the foothills of Elias. I conducted two group interviews involving 12 mothers who solicited private tutoring for spoken English. And the group interviews were about two, two and a half hours long. and they were held in tutorial centers after the participants scheduled spoken English sessions. So this was a deliberate attempt

05:13 - because they didn't wanna talk to me about their experiences of taking tuition as adults in their homes. And so I purposely chose that the site has to be somewhere they felt most comfortable. So therefore, it was a tutorial center. The, the key findings really were that mother's reason for subscribing to tutorial, services and coaching for spoken English tends to be threefold. First is, English proficiency for effective home teaching so

05:47 - that they can be a good teacher for their kids at home. Second is to reinforce English as a language of communication. And the third was that English tutoring, for effective partnership with school teachers. So as a synthesis of the main argument, if you will, would be that English private tutoring was really seen by these mothers as a way to unlock urban middle class identity and privilege, which they felt they did not

06:17 - quite belong to this group. And this was their way to say, Hey, actually I am middle class. So it's to gain social legitimacy of being a middle class, given that they did not quite feel that they were part of the group. So I will just go through each of these three reasons one by one just to expand on it. the first one was English proficiency for effective home teaching.

06:40 - So we know from the literature about the school choice, both of the middle class parents, especially because I spoke with, middle to upper middle class parents, they often or not often, they always made sure that they were enrolling their children to high fee as opposed to low fee private schools, where the medium of instruction was always English. teaching at home, was seen by these parents as the most valuable form of parenting.

07:11 - and so English proficiency was one of the crucial skills for them to provide effective teaching and learning support to their children at home. So if I were to read just one extract from my study, one of the mothers, for example, said, when I spent time with my kids, I realize that English proficiency is necessary for us referring to other mothers to be just able to engage in their children's everyday subject best lessons, as well as everyday learning.

07:41 - It is like, I know the topic, but don't know how to say things in English. I know for example, what group ion is, but it does not easily translate into gravity for me. so ion is the, ate handy word for gravity. so this really illustrates how mothers felt that proficiency in English would allow them to become really effective teachers at home, which they thought was really very part of their parenting. The second reason was reinforcing English as a language

08:17 - of communication. So there's always this perceived language gap between themselves and their children. This was talked about by all the mothers, predominantly because they were all, learning subjects in English and mothers themselves even went to school. They all learned those subjects in Hindi or Ular language. for majority of them it was Hindi. So it prevented productive

08:46 - and constructive interaction interactions about school related matters. So if mothers wanted to know what the child was doing, they wouldn't fully grasp because the notes would be prepared in English. And when they would speak with their kids, kids might use some of the languages that they would not really be familiar with. So they always felt this language gap was actually becoming a gap between them knowing about what is going on in school.

09:11 - so this obviously had negative impact on substantial difference in linguistic environment at home and at school, meaning the environment, linguistic environment in school was English and linguistic environment in home tended to be Hindi or Ari language, which yeah, really languages. So an except from the interview is, so mother says, some teachers also think that if we continue talking to our kids in Hindi at home, they, the children are more likely to struggle to learn how

09:46 - to speak English fluently in the school environment. So if there is continuity in language at home and in school, children are more likely to progress with fewer difficulties. The purpose here was that was that mothers wanted to make their children's life a little bit easier and parents said this would be the remedy, so therefore they subscribe to private tutoring. The third reason was that English tutoring for effective partnership with school teachers.

10:16 - This sort of ex extends from the point that I raised just now. so when we talk about school choice again in India, we see that educators' ability to communicate in English to train children in a culture of sharing and exchanging ideas in English. So this is why, the school choice of choosing a, a school that serves English as a medium of instruction. however, this culture disparity between the school teachers and mothers,

10:47 - because mothers cannot communicate in that language, produced an interesting intra class dynamic. Now, why intra class dynamic is because whilst mothers claim to be middle class school teachers were also middle class. But the point here is that they both belong to different strands of middle class. They became middle class very differently, in other words. so the extract reads. sometimes I also struggle

11:14 - to understand when teachers speak English fluently. Some teachers pronounce words differently from how many people I know would pronounce them even if they were communicating in English. So I just do not know what they're saying. This is incredibly challenging because I sometimes miss out on in important information. So this accent part is really important. language ability for the traditional middle class to be able to communicate ideas fluently in English was very

11:43 - much inherent to their middle class identity, not so much for many groups in new middle class category. And so it shows the intra class dynamic and the disparity in how one becomes middle class. This paper basically signifies that tutoring could be used for unlocking a class identity. So in this case, mothers were using tutoring for unlocking urban middle class identity for themselves. it speaks to the contemporary understanding of middle class identity

12:17 - and privilege, broadly speaking outside of India, because just like in India, the way in which one becomes middle class is increasingly becoming much more diverse than used to be the case in the past. so therefore the new research agenda could be to really map those trajectories and see to what extent does it result into the kind of advantage in education and sports and health in other fields as well.

12:45 - so that would be one way to approach it. The second is that what I try to touch on in this paper is under examine territory of parental investment in their children's education. So I try to move away from the discussions on parental investments from the lens of educational choices that parents make for their children to parental investment in themselves. overall, the purpose of mothers to seek tutoring for spoken English was

13:14 - to ensure their children had sufficient resources to achieve their full academic potential. And so future research can examine what is going on at home rather than just looking at what is going on in between schools and home or just what is going on in the school. So that's the second contribution and sort of draws line for what could be done in the future with regards to research projects. The third point that I try to highlight in this paper is

13:45 - to signify middle class mothers' efforts to unlock their social class identity. Class identity is not always given, and that's what I try to sort of tease out, especially through that intra class dynamic between school teachers and parents both belong to middle class. They're very different kind of middle class. so many middle class mothers realize that they are economically middle class, they've got money still.

14:14 - They lack that critical cultural resources such as English proficiency, which traditionally, was associated with being middle class in India. So that shows how trajectory could be really important. Signifier to the, to inform whether or not you actually feel you belong to the group, you belong to a group is a different question. You feel you belong to a group is another. And so if future research could tease out those kind of differences and

14:46 - how those differences are experienced on the ground, that could be a interesting project In and of itself, particularly to elicit how then educational advantage and disadvantage, look like even in a very diversified format within one particular social class.

Faculti AI can make mistakes